# Guest Column: The False Religious Argument Over the Burqa

- Link: https://rightsidenews.com/life-and-science/culture-wars/guest-column-the-false-religious-argument-over-the-burqa/
- Published: 2013-08-06T16:35:32-05:00
- Author: Right News

by Abigail R. Esman Special to IPT News

[The Investigative Project on Terrorism](http://www.investigativeproject.org/4113/guest-column-the-false-religious-argument-over)

⌊860 large⌉⌊860 large⌉For two days, they burned cars. They shouted about racism 
and attacked police, hurling stones and shattering windows of the local police department.
In Trappes, France, the [riots](http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/22/france-riots-niqab-burqa-ban-defended)
that broke out last month over laws against wearing a niqab (or veil) in public 
threatened lives, disrupted the country, and raised, yet again, questions about 
conflicts between the culture of France’s secular democracy and much of its Muslim
population. And though such riots take place frequently in France (in 2005, they
ended only after the government was forced to impose a state of emergency), those
conflicts – and the issues they represent – seem no closer to resolution.

This time, the trouble broke out after police, conducting a routine identity check,
stopped a woman wearing niqab in Trappes, near Versailles, on July 18. When they
asked her to remove the face-covering, her husband – a French-born convert to Islam–
allegedly attempted [to strangle](http://www.timesofisrael.com/5-injured-in-clashes-at-burka-riot-outside-paris/)
one of the officers. He was immediately arrested, but the riots broke out soon after.
By July 20, nearly 1,000 of Trappes’ 30,000 inhabitants had joined the violent clashes,
which spread to nearby neighborhoods.

The events have reignited concern over a number of issues regarding the clashes 
between Muslim and non-Muslim communities that continue to plague France, which 
has the largest population of Muslims in Europe (numbering about 5 million). These
same issues, in fact, have come to haunt all of Europe as its Muslim population 
grows, and, with it, the radicalization of European Muslim youth.

France [banned](http://www.investigativeproject.org/2783/op-ed-why-muslims-should-support-burqa-ban)
the burqa and the niqab, both of which hide women’s faces, in 2010, imposing a fine
on women who continue to wear the garments in public. (The law became active one
year later.) Belgium and the Netherlands have since followed suit, and the idea 
is repeatedly broached in other European countries. Supporters of the policy claim
that the burqa and niqab oppress women and violate Western mores; and that the inability
to see a person’s face presents a security risk to the public. Opponents maintain
that the garments represent a religious mandate, and that such bans constitute religious
discrimination and infringe on the rights of Muslim women – though in truth, there
is nothing in the Koran that mandates any such form of dress. Yet others argue more
simply that the subject of wardrobe choice is not and should not land in the realm
of the law.

In an ideal world, perhaps this last argument would be the case; but in fact, niqab-
clad women – and men – have used the garment as a tool in committing crimes from
robbery (including a string of five [bank robberies](http://content.usatoday.com/communities/ondeadline/post/2012/04/philly-criminals-use-womens-islamic-garb-instead-of-masks/1#.UflbRKWYnww)
in Pennsylvania) to [kidnapping](http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-21476508)
and [worse](http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/crime/10027898/Woman-21-charged-in-niqab-acid-attack.html),
relying on the ease with which they can move about entirely anonymously within.

Moreover, with so-called “burqa bans” in place in a number of Muslim countries including
Turkey and Tunisia, the law hardly, as many Western Muslims argue, represents a 
form of institutionalized “Islamophobia.” Indeed, barely more than 400 French Muslim
women have been cited for violating the ban, indicating that several million of 
their French sisters have been unaffected in the practice of their religion.

Interestingly, too, most of those who have persisted in wearing the niqab are [under age 30](http://www.lejdd.fr/Societe/Faits-divers/Actualite/Voile-integral-plus-de-400-femmes-verbalisees-dont-5-multirecidivistes-620281),
according to _Le Journal du Dimanche._ That fact meshes with signs that many of 
Europe’s young Muslims are becoming more religiously conservative, often in rebellion
against the Western traditions of the countries in which they live – and in most
cases, were born and raised.

What’s more, [Abdallah Zekri](http://www.lemonde.fr/sujet/1e08/abdallah-zekri.html),
president of L’observatoire de l’Islamophobie, a French Muslim rights organization,
[says](http://www.lemonde.fr/societe/article/2013/07/24/les-agressions-contre-des-femmes-portant-le-foulard-inquietent_3452692_3224.html)
that the majority of these women are converts. They “understand nothing about Islam
or the Koran, who want to be more Muslim than Muslims._“_

In France, as elsewhere, it is both young, Western-born Muslims and Muslim converts
who are the easier and more frequent targets for Al Qaeda recruiters, and for radical
imams seeking to build Shariah-ruled communities in the West. The niqab fight is,
in effect, simply a manifestation of this.

And that, argues the French state and other proponents of the ban, is quite the 
point: the niqab has nothing to do with religion, and everything to do with the 
politics of culture, in this case, that reflect a very real threat to the Enlightenment
values of the West. As one American Muslim woman (who asked to remain anonymous 
given the sensitive nature of the subject) told me, “the niqab isn’t even an Islamic
code of dress.”

“The Prophet’s wives did not dress like this,” said the woman, a Pakistani-American
Muslim who divides her time between the two countries, “and so I don’t understand
this radical interpretation. In fact, it’s not even an interpretation. It’s just
crazy.”

### Share:

 * [  Facebook ](https://rightsidenews.com/life-and-science/culture-wars/guest-column-the-false-religious-argument-over-the-burqa/?share=facebook)
 * [  Email ](https://rightsidenews.com/life-and-science/culture-wars/guest-column-the-false-religious-argument-over-the-burqa/?subject=%5BShared%20Post%5D%20Guest%20Column%3A%20The%20False%20Religious%20Argument%20Over%20the%20Burqa&body=https%3A%2F%2Frightsidenews.com%2Flife-and-science%2Fculture-wars%2Fguest-column-the-false-religious-argument-over-the-burqa%2F&share=email)
 * [  Telegram ](https://rightsidenews.com/life-and-science/culture-wars/guest-column-the-false-religious-argument-over-the-burqa/?share=telegram)
 * [  Reddit ](https://rightsidenews.com/life-and-science/culture-wars/guest-column-the-false-religious-argument-over-the-burqa/?share=reddit)
 * [  X ](https://rightsidenews.com/life-and-science/culture-wars/guest-column-the-false-religious-argument-over-the-burqa/?share=twitter)
 * [  LinkedIn ](https://rightsidenews.com/life-and-science/culture-wars/guest-column-the-false-religious-argument-over-the-burqa/?share=linkedin)
 * [  Print ](https://rightsidenews.com/life-and-science/culture-wars/guest-column-the-false-religious-argument-over-the-burqa/#print?share=print)
 * [  Nextdoor ](https://rightsidenews.com/life-and-science/culture-wars/guest-column-the-false-religious-argument-over-the-burqa/?share=nextdoor)

### Like this:

Like Loading…
