# U. S. Legislative Immigration Update April 2, 2012

- Link: https://rightsidenews.com/us/homeland-security/u-s-legislative-immigration-update-april-2-2012/
- Published: 2012-04-02T20:17:42-05:00
- Author: Right News

April 2, 2012 Right Side News Reports from the·[Federation for American Immigration Reform ](http://www.fairus.org/site/PageNavigator/homepagenew)(
FAIR) in this legislative weekly including: 
Obama Administration Expands Backdoor
Amnesty | USCIS Proposes Rule to Circumvent Federal Laws on Admission | Court Will
Drop DUI Charges for Obama’s Illegal Alien Uncle | California Sides with Illegal
Aliens before the Supreme Court | Republicans Draft DREAM Act Alternatives in Advance
of Elections

### Obama Administration Expands Backdoor Amnesty ⌊bald_eagle_head_and_american_flag1⌉

The Obama Administration announced Thursday that it will be expanding its backdoor
amnesty program to four major U.S. cities: Detroit, Seattle, New Orleans, and Orlando.(
[_Washington Post_](http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/dhs-expanding-deportation-case-reviews-to-4-more-cities-will-temporarily-suspend-court-docket/2012/03/29/gIQArp5YjS_story.html),
Mar. 29, 2012) The expansion of the program, slated to take place from April 23 
to May 4, means that the Department of Justice will entirely suspend the immigration
court dockets in these four cities.  (_Id._; [_Huffington Post_](https://rightsidenews.com/us/homeland-security/u-s-legislative-immigration-update-april-2-2012/#s332934&title=DREAM_Act_Students),
Mar. 30, 2012) Then, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) attorneys will review
the deportation cases of aliens not in custody and administratively close the cases
they feel are not a priority pursuant to ICE guidelines. (_See _FAIR’s [Morton Memos](http://www.fairus.org/morton-memos-summary)
Summary)

The expansion continues the backdoor amnesty program launched by Homeland Security
Secretary Janet Napolitano in August 2011. (_See_ Napolitano [letter](http://democrats.senate.gov/uploads/2011/08/11_8949_Reid_Dream_Act_response_08.18.11.pdf),
Aug. 18, 2011) Since that announcement, ICE has issued guidelines to its agents 
on which cases should be administratively closed and which cases are enforcement
priorities. ICE began the deportation review through two pilot programs it launched
in Baltimore and Denver last December.  (_See _FAIR’s  [Morton Memos](http://www.fairus.org/morton-memos-summary)
Summary)

The announcement of an expansion is at odds with statements by Administration officials
earlier this month that it was already half-way complete with its review of pending
deportation cases. While testifying before the House Appropriations Homeland Security
Subcommittee March 8, ICE Director John Morton claimed the Administration was already
half-way through its review of the estimated 300,000 pending cases on immigration
court dockets. (_See Bloomberg Government Transcript_, Mar. 9, 2012; _see also _FAIR
[Legislative Update](https://rightsidenews.com/us/homeland-security/u-s-legislative-immigration-update-april-2-2012/#2),
Mar. 12, 2012) Director Morton claimed as a result of this review his agency had
closed merely 1,500 cases, despite DHS claims that it was closing the cases of over
1,600 illegal aliens from the Denver and Baltimore pilots alone. ([_NY Times_](http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/20/us/in-test-of-deportation-policy-1-in-6-offered-reprieve.html?_r=1),
Jan. 19, 2012)  A day later, the ICE emailed Members of Congress a correction (_See
_ICE [email](http://www.immigrationpolicy.org/sites/default/files/docs/dhs-email-to-hill-03-09-2012-converted.pdf),
Mar. 9, 2012) stating that as of March 5, ICE administratively closed or dismissed
nearly 1,600 cases, but deemed an additional roughly 11,000 eligible for closure.(
_Id._)

Attorneys across the country are crowing about how their clients are reaping the
benefits of the Administration’s backdoor amnesty initiatives before the reviews
officially reach their cities.  For example, Seattle immigration attorney Sharon
Underwood claimed several of her clients have already benefited from the Administration’s
priorities and signaled the review that is supposed to begin in April was already
underway. She told the [_Seattle Times_](http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/localnews/2017870000_detained30m.html)
thatICE’s chief counsel Rafael SÃ¡nchez told immigration attorneys at a recent regional
meeting that ICE attorneys are _currently_ reviewing every case and closing 17 percent
of them. ([_Seattle Times_](http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/localnews/2017870000_detained30m.html)_,
_Mar. 29, 2012)

After ICE administratively closes cases in these four cities, it plans to move to
other major U.S. cities. The Administration announced that it would partially suspend
the non-detained alien docket in New York City May 7 to May 18, in San Francisco
June 4 to June 15, and then in Los Angeles from July 9 to July 20. ([_Huffington Post_](https://rightsidenews.com/us/homeland-security/u-s-legislative-immigration-update-april-2-2012/#s332934&title=DREAM_Act_Students),
Mar. 30, 2012)

### USCIS Proposes Rule to Circumvent Federal Laws on Admission

Nearly three months after making a public announcement, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration
Services (USCIS) released its proposed rule to allow illegal aliens to circumvent
federal statutes that govern admission. (_See _[Proposed Rule](http://www.ofr.gov/OFRUpload/OFRData/2012-07698_PI.pdf),
Mar. 30, 2012; _see also _USCIS [website](http://www.uscis.gov/portal/site/uscis/menuitem.eb1d4c2a3e5b9ac89243c6a7543f6d1a/?vgnextoid=bc41875decf56310VgnVCM100000082ca60aRCRD&vgnextchannel=bc41875decf56310VgnVCM100000082ca60aRCRD))
This latest move by the Obama Administration makes it easier for illegal alien family
members of U.S. citizens to stay in the U.S. and become citizens themselves. The
USCIS proposed rule does this by creating broad exceptions to the 3 and 10-year 
bar to admission found in Section 212 of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA).

To help deter illegal immigration and marriage fraud, in 1996 Congress added the
3 and 10 year bars to Section 212 of the INA.  Section 212 provides that an alien
who has been in the U.S. unlawfully for 180 days to one year and leaves is inadmissible
to the U.S. for three years; aliens unlawfully in the U.S. for a year or more who
leave are inadmissible for ten years.  (_See_ INA § 212(a)(9)(B)(i))  USCIS may 
grant certain illegal alien relatives a waiver to the 3 and 10-year bar, but the
illegal alien must apply for the waiver outside of the U.S. at a consular office.(
INA § 212(a)(9)(B)(v))

The Administration’s proposed rule, however, would skirt this statute by allowing
certain illegal alien relatives of U.S. citizens to stay in the U.S. and apply for
a green card.  (_See _Proposed Rule § III(D))  Specifically, the rule allows these
illegal aliens to apply for and receive a “provisional waiver” of the 3 and 10-year
bar while in the U.S., so long as they can show that being separated from their 
_U.S. citizen spouse or parent_ would cause that U.S. citizen relative “extreme 
hardship.”  Once the illegal alien receives a provisional waiver, the he may stay
in the country and apply for a green card.

The core impact of the Administration’s proposed rule will be to encourage relatives
of U.S. citizens to come the U.S. illegally. All the alien will need to do is apply
for a provisional waiver from the 3 and 10-year bar and apply for a green card. 
If USCIS grants the illegal alien a provisional waiver under the new rule, the illegal
alien gets to stay and the waiver will become final once the State Department determines
the illegal alien is eligible for a green card.  (_See _Proposed Rule at§ IV(A))
If USCIS denies the application for a provisional waiver, ICE will not prosecute
the illegal alien for immigration violations.  ICE announced in August 2011 that
it would seek to dismiss the prosecution of cases of illegal alien relatives who
have applied for a green card, so long as the illegal alien is otherwise eligible.(
[Morton Memo](http://www.ice.gov/doclib/detention-reform/pdf/aliens-pending-applications.pdf),
Aug. 20, 2011) Finally, illegal alien family members who leave the U.S. are still
eligible to apply for a waiver using the current statutory process.  (_Id._)

House Judiciary Chairman Lamar Smith (R-TX) scolded the Administration for circumventing
Congressional intent that immigration laws be enforced. “President Obama is bending
long established immigration laws…Congress instituted the three and 10 year bars
in 1996 to provide a penalty for immigrants who had been illegally present in the
U.S. for long periods of time.  While the waiver of these bars is legal under current
law, it is not intended to be applied to millions of illegal immigrants.” (_See 
_House Judiciary [Press Release](http://judiciary.house.gov/news/03302012.html),
Mar. 30, 2012)

### Court Will Drop DUI Charges for Obama’s Illegal Alien Uncle

On Tuesday, President Obama’s uncle, Onyango “Omar” Obama, surrendered his driver’s
license to the State of Massachusetts for a 45-day suspension. The suspension was
agreed to in a plea bargain that could ultimately allow Mr. Obama to remain in the
country illegally. ([_Boston Herald_](http://www.bostonherald.com/news/regional/view.bg?articleid=1061120377&srvc=rss),
March 27, 2012)

The surrender his driver’s license is the latest development in a case that began
last August when Mr. Obama was arrested for driving erratically and operating a 
vehicle while under the influence of alcohol (DUI) at nearly twice the legal limit.(
_Id._) Upon arrest, Mr. Obama was briefly detained by ICE officials when they discovered
that Obama had ignored a 20-year-old deportation order. Mr. Obama’s immigration 
case is currently pending. ([_Boston Herald_](http://news.bostonherald.com/news/regional/view/20220328obamas_uncle_loses_drivers_license/)_,_
March 28, 2012; _see also_ FAIR [Legislative Update](https://rightsidenews.com/us/homeland-security/u-s-legislative-immigration-update-april-2-2012/#1),
Sept. 6, 2011)

After Obama ‘s apprehension, Massachusetts Judge Douglas Stoddard put the case on
hold for one year and effectively dismissed Obama’s DUI charges under the terms 
of the plea arrangement. ([_Chicago Tribune_](http://www.chicagotribune.com/sns-rt-usa-obamaunclel2e8qr0jf-20120327,0,7729786.story),
March 27, 2012) The plea deal also provides that so long as Mr. Obama is not arrested
again this year, the Court will erase the drunk-driving charges from his record.(
[_The Hill_](http://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/news/218439-obamas-uncle-omar-enters-plea-on-drunk-driving-charges),
March 27, 2012)

Alarmingly, erasing Mr. Obama’s charges will improve his chances of being permitted
to remain in the country illegally. According to the Obama Administration’s backdoor
amnesty initiative, immigration officers are ordered to ignore illegal aliens who
have no criminal record. (_See _FAIR [Morton Memos Summary](http://www.fairus.org/morton-memos-summary),
Jan. 2012)

Scott Bratton, Mr. Obama’s attorney, claimed the plea bargain will have “little 
if any impact upon his immigration case” and argued that Mr. Obama should be granted
amnesty simply because “he’s been here since 1963.” ([_Chicago Tribune_](http://www.chicagotribune.com/sns-rt-usa-obamaunclel2e8qr0jf-20120327,0,7729786.story),
March 27, 2012; _see also_ [_Boston Herald_](http://news.bostonherald.com/news/regional/view/20220328obamas_uncle_loses_drivers_license/),
March 28, 2012)

The plea bargain won’t keep Mr. Obama from driving, either. Despite surrendering
his license, Mr. Obama has the ability to apply for a hardship license as a first-
time DUI offender, and he expressed that he plans to do just that. Mr. Obama returned
to his job as manager at Conti’s Liquors last week, even though federal law expressly
prohibits illegal aliens from working in the United States. (_See _INA § 274A(h)(
3); [_Washington Post_](http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/obamas-uncle-enters-plea-in-mass-drunken-driving-case-charge-will-be-dismissed-after-a-year/2012/03/27/gIQAztmMeS_story.html)_,
_March 28, 2012)

Mr. Onyango Obama is not the first illegal alien in President Obama’s family. His
Aunt, Zeituni Onyango, who is Onyango’s sister, openly defied immigration laws by
staying in the country illegally despite twice being ordered deported by an immigration
judge. After years of living in taxpayer-subsidized housing and collecting government
disability checks, she told an interviewer from CBS News that the U.S. government
was obligated to take care of her and to make her a U.S. citizen. (_See_ FAIR [Website](http://www.fairus.org/issue/obamas-aunt-a-symbol-of-u-s-immigration-policy-abuse),
2009; _see also_ FAIR [Legislative Update](http://www.fairus.org/legislative-updates/fair-legislative-update-september-27-2010),
Sept. 27, 2010)

### California Sides with Illegal Aliens before the Supreme Court

Last week, the State of California and several other states, filed a brief with 
the United States Supreme Court urging the Court to strike down Arizona’s immigration
enforcement law, SB 1070.  (California [Amicus Brief](http://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/publications/supreme_court_preview/briefs/11-182_respondentamcu11states.authcheckdam.pdf))
The Supreme Court is scheduled to hear oral arguments on the Obama Administration’s
challenge to SB 1070 April 25th and in anticipation, dozens of interested parties,
organizations, and even foreign governments have filed briefs both in support and
opposition to the law. The other states joining California in the amicus brief are
New York, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Iowa, Maryland, Massachusetts, Oregon, 
Rhode Island, and Vermont.

The core of California’s objection to SB 1070 rests on the notion that through SB
1070, Arizona has impermissibly adopted its own removal policy — a power CA argues
is “exclusively [a] federal function.” (CA Brief at 3)  While states have no authority
to remove (deport) illegal aliens (nor is the state of Arizona claiming such authority),
California argues that the enforcement activities Arizona is encouraging through
SB 1070 – the identification, apprehension, and detention of illegal aliens – are
by definition part of the removal process.  Thus, Arizona has adopted its own “removal
policy.”

California then argues that Arizona’s removal policy, as embodied by SB 1070, is
impermissible because it conflicts with the federal removal “scheme.” (_Id._)  Federal
law, California asserts, has long recognized that immigration enforcement has “uniquely
devastating effects” on “people who are otherwise law abiding and productive members
of society.”  (_Id._)  Describing SB 1070 an “overzealous and indiscriminate attempt”
to enforce the law, California argues that Arizona’s law conflicts with “federal
removal policy” in two ways.  (CA Brief at 3, 9).  First, California claims that
SB 1070 requires state and local officers to engage in the arrest and detention 
of illegal aliens without any federal oversight.  Second, California argues that
SB 1070 supplants the Executive Branch’s discretion over the administration of the
removal process and thus “interferes with the achievement of the federal priorities
Congress has set.” (CA Brief at 3-4)  California then concludes that because SB 
1070 conflicts with this federal removal scheme, it is preempted by federal law.

Through this argument, however, California ignores the simple fact that nothing 
in SB 1070 supplants the authority of the federal government to decide whether to
remove an illegal alien.  To the contrary, SB 1070 merely requires Arizona officers
to verify immigration status in certain circumstances and report it to the federal
government.  The law also creates state offenses that mirror already existing federal
laws.

California’s argument also ignores that numerous federal statutes actually authorize
and encourage local officers to identify, apprehend, and detain illegal aliens. 
For example, Section 1373(c) of the United States Code requires that the federal
government respond to all local inquiries about immigration status.  Section 1373(
a)-(b) prohibits laws that interfere with the sharing of immigration data between
local governments and the federal government.  And, Section 1357(g)(10) provides
that local law enforcement does not need to enter into an agreement with the federal
government to cooperate in the enforcement of immigration laws.  (_See also_ INA§
287(g)(10))

In addition, California ignores that the Administration itself will soon require
all jurisdictions – through the implementation of Secure Communities – to identify
illegal aliens booked at jails (before conviction).  And, through regulations, the
Administration also requires that local jurisdictions detain illegal aliens if federal
immigration officers place a hold on them (called a detainer).  (_See_ 8 C.F.R. 
287.7(d))

Finally, California’s argument ignores a plethora of case law that confirms that
state and local authorities have the inherent or general enforcement authority to
assist in the enforcement of immigration laws.  _See e.g. United States v. Salinas-
Calderon_ (10th Cir. 1982); _United States v. Vasquez-Alvarez_ (10th Cir. 1999).

SB 1070 therefore does nothing more than further Congressional intent that local
jurisdictions participate in the identification, apprehension, and detention of 
illegal aliens. Moreover, because Congress has encouraged, and in some cases required,
local jurisdictions to engage in these activities, California cannot reasonably 
argue that they are equal to the removal of illegal aliens — a power Congress has
reserved for the federal government.

### Republicans Draft DREAM Act Alternatives in Advance of Elections

Reacting to concerns that Republican candidates are in danger of losing the Hispanic
vote in November, several GOP lawmakers have declared their plans to introduce modified
versions of the failed DREAM Act, hoping to win votes.

The most recent lawmaker to announce a new proposal is Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL). 
While the Senator has not yet filed official language, he expressed that his focus
will be on helping young illegal aliens. One suggestion Rubio proffered involves
creating a new student visa to allow illegal alien students “to finish their studies
until they can apply legally.” ([_FOX News Latino_](http://latino.foxnews.com/latino/news/2012/03/27/republicans-craft-watered-down-version-dream-act/),
March 27, 2012; _see also_ [_The Hill_](http://thehill.com/homenews/senate/218307-republicans-seeking-out-hispanics),
March 27, 2012) Sen. Rubio has opposed previous versions of the DREAM Act, including
the bill most recently rejected by the Senate in 2010. ([_Tampa Bay Times_](http://www.tampabay.com/blogs/the-buzz-florida-politics/content/rubio-maintains-opposition-dream-act),
Nov. 19, 2010)

[_The Hill_](http://thehill.com/homenews/senate/218307-republicans-seeking-out-hispanics)
reports that Sens. Jon Kyl (R-AZ) and Kay Bailey Hutchison (R-TX) are also working
on a separate DREAM Act alternative, but have refused to release any details about
their plan until after the Republican nomination is finalized. ([_The Hill_](http://thehill.com/homenews/senate/218307-republicans-seeking-out-hispanics),
March 27, 2012)

In the House, Rep. David Rivera (R-FL) has announced plans to introduce the Studying
Towards Adjusted Residency Status (STARS) Act, which he intends to file soon. The
bill will allow illegal aliens 18 and-a-half or younger, who arrived in the U.S.
before the age of 16, and who have lived in the country for the five previous years,
to be granted amnesty if they graduate from a four-year institution. (Rep. Rivera
[Press Release](http://rivera.house.gov/press-release/congressman-rivera-announces-studying-towards-adjusted-residency-status-stars-act),
March 9, 2012)

If passed, the DREAM Act would grant amnesty to illegal aliens who entered the country
as children and have met minimal educational requirements. Some versions of the 
Act would also amend current law to allow states to provide subsidized in-state 
tuition to illegal aliens, shifting the cost burden to American taxpayers. (_See_
FAIR DREAM Act [Summary](http://www.fairus.org/docs/Dream_Act09.pdf), 2009)

### Share:

 * [  Facebook ](https://rightsidenews.com/us/homeland-security/u-s-legislative-immigration-update-april-2-2012/?share=facebook)
 * [  Email ](https://rightsidenews.com/us/homeland-security/u-s-legislative-immigration-update-april-2-2012/?subject=%5BShared%20Post%5D%20U.%20S.%20Legislative%20Immigration%20Update%20April%202%2C%202012&body=https%3A%2F%2Frightsidenews.com%2Fus%2Fhomeland-security%2Fu-s-legislative-immigration-update-april-2-2012%2F&share=email)
 * [  Telegram ](https://rightsidenews.com/us/homeland-security/u-s-legislative-immigration-update-april-2-2012/?share=telegram)
 * [  Reddit ](https://rightsidenews.com/us/homeland-security/u-s-legislative-immigration-update-april-2-2012/?share=reddit)
 * [  X ](https://rightsidenews.com/us/homeland-security/u-s-legislative-immigration-update-april-2-2012/?share=twitter)
 * [  LinkedIn ](https://rightsidenews.com/us/homeland-security/u-s-legislative-immigration-update-april-2-2012/?share=linkedin)
 * [  Print ](https://rightsidenews.com/us/homeland-security/u-s-legislative-immigration-update-april-2-2012/#print?share=print)
 * [  Nextdoor ](https://rightsidenews.com/us/homeland-security/u-s-legislative-immigration-update-april-2-2012/?share=nextdoor)

### Like this:

Like Loading…
