Britain’s Court of Appeal has set aside two tribunal decisions that blocked the Home Office from deporting a Slovak man who served about eight years of a 13-year sentence for drug dealing and illicit firearms trafficking. The court found that the first tribunal judge applied the wrong legal threshold and “apparently lost sight of” the gun convictions. The case now goes back for a fresh hearing, more than five years after the Home Office first told him he faced deportation.
On November 11, 2026, the Court of Appeal allowed the Home Secretary’s appeal in Secretary of State for the Home Department v Frantisek Barus [2026] EWCA Civ 1447. (The Home Secretary appears in court papers as the Secretary of State for the Home Department, or SSHD.) Lord Justice Bean, Vice-President of the Court of Appeal’s Civil Division, gave the only reasoned judgment. Lord Justice Phillips and Lord Justice Stuart-Smith agreed.
The court did not order Mr Barus’s deportation. It sent the case back to the Upper Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) “for a freshly constituted tribunal” to hear his appeal again (judgment, para. 34). But its reasoning is pointed. A drug dealer with unauthorised firearms at his disposal, Lord Justice Bean wrote, “is plainly a more dangerous individual and poses a greater danger to public security than a drug dealer who does not” (judgment, para. 32).
What the coverage has missed
RSN’s searches found no report of the ruling in national news outlets in the nine days after it was handed down. It has been written up by the specialist immigration law site Free Movement. Three points deserve wider attention.
First, it took three rounds of appeals to correct the original decision. The First-tier Tribunal allowed Mr Barus’s appeal in May 2023. The Home Office’s challenge in the Upper Tribunal was confined to the disclosure point and failed. Only in the Court of Appeal, where the department’s barrister, Zane Malik KC, argued that the first tribunal had applied too high a threshold and mishandled rehabilitation, did three senior judges find that the decision rested on a legal error and an incomplete picture of the offending (judgment, paras. 11, 13 and 14).
Second, the Home Office itself contributed to the outcome. Its central complaint was that Mr Barus had described his record on his settlement application only as a “Drug-related offence”, leaving out the firearms convictions. The Court of Appeal agreed that answer was “misleading”. It also held that the tribunal could not be blamed for ignoring it, because “it was never put to him in cross-examination that this answer was dishonest” (judgment, para. 32). The Home Office was represented at that hearing by a Presenting Officer.
Third, the time involved. The Home Office served notice of liability to deportation on August 12, 2021. The Court of Appeal ruled on November 11, 2026, five years and three months later, and the case still has no final answer.
Background: a 13-year sentence and a settlement application
According to the judgment, Mr Barus is a Slovak citizen. In March 2011 he was convicted in Slovakia “of offences related to drug-dealing and illicit trafficking in firearms” and sentenced to 13 years’ imprisonment (judgment, para. 2). He was released in March 2019 and arrived in the United Kingdom in June of that year.
In November 2020, weeks before the end of the Brexit transition period, he applied for leave to remain under the EU Settlement Scheme (EUSS). The online form asked: “Have you ever been convicted of a criminal offence or arrested or charged with an offence that you are on trial for or awaiting trial?” He answered “Yes”. Asked “What crime were you convicted of?”, he wrote “Drug-related offence” (judgment, para. 3).
The Home Office decided in January 2022 to make a deportation order. Its decision letter recorded one count of supplying a controlled drug, with a 13-year sentence, and two counts relating to the manufacture, sale or transfer of firearms by someone who was not a registered dealer. It said Mr Barus had “failed to declare the full extent of your foreign criminality within your application” (judgment, paras. 4 and 5). On March 28, 2022, the department refused his settlement application because he was subject to the deportation order (judgment, para. 8).
Because his offending took place before the end of 2020 and he applied to the scheme in time, his case is governed by the Immigration (European Economic Area) Regulations 2016. Those regulations were revoked at the end of 2020 but are preserved for cases like his (judgment, paras. 18 to 20). Under regulation 27, the Home Office may deport an EU citizen on “public policy” grounds only if his personal conduct represents “a genuine, present and sufficiently serious threat affecting one of the fundamental interests of society”. Previous convictions do not, on their own, justify deportation. EU citizens with permanent residence get stronger protection, and those with ten years’ residence stronger still. Mr Barus had lived in Britain for less than five years, so he had only the basic level of protection.
The tribunal decisions
First-tier Tribunal Judge Elliott heard Mr Barus’s appeal in Birmingham on March 6, 2023, and allowed it in a decision promulgated on May 24, 2023 (judgment, para. 9). The judge did not take a light view of the offending. He found that Mr Barus “was part of an organised conspiracy to supply highly addictive Class A drugs” and that his motive was financial. He noted the absence of any probation assessment or official evidence supporting Mr Barus’s account of rehabilitation (judgment, para. 10, quoting the tribunal at paras. 55 and 58).
The judge accepted that the conduct “was capable of presenting a sufficiently serious threat”. He nonetheless concluded: “In my opinion the high threshold for the deportation of an EEA national is not met in this case.” He found Mr Barus posed “no genuine and present threat”, pointing to his lack of offending in Britain, employment, a relationship with a partner he had become engaged to, and the support of relatives living in the UK (judgment, para. 10, quoting the tribunal at paras. 61 to 69). In one passage the tribunal gave the sentence as 11 years. The correct figure is 13.
The Home Office appealed. Upper Tribunal Judge Perkins, granting permission, described one of the department’s two grounds as “very weak”; that ground was later dropped (judgment, paras. 12 and 13). On the remaining ground, Upper Tribunal Judge Lane dismissed the appeal. He held that the first judge had been aware of the incomplete disclosure. He also wrote that “the Secretary of State does not appear to have made submissions on this particular matter at the First-tier Tribunal hearing” (judgment, para. 13, quoting the Upper Tribunal at para. 6).
What the Court of Appeal decided
Lord Justice Coulson granted permission for a further appeal, noting “a wider point of principle concerned with the nature, scope and extend [sic] of a regulation 27 assessment, and the relevance (or otherwise) of matters such as rehabilitation and proportionality” (judgment, para. 15).
Mr Barus’s counsel, Ramby de Mello and Edward Nicholson, argued in a Respondent’s Notice that the Home Office should have obtained fuller records from the Slovak police and had wrongly described the firearms convictions. The court allowed them to raise those points, then rejected them. Lord Justice Bean said they had “no merit at all” (judgment, para. 27). He cited an English translation of part of the Slovak judgment, a record obtained by the UK’s criminal records exchange office (ACRO) listing two firearms offences, and a Police National Computer printout recording the same convictions. “What is clear,” he wrote, “is that the criminal conduct of which Mr Barus was convicted and sentenced to a long term of imprisonment included illicit dealings in firearms” (judgment, paras. 27 to 31).
On the Home Office’s appeal, the court identified two errors. The key passage reads:
“Firstly, it is not correct to say that in seeking to deport an EEA-national foreign criminal who has committed a serious offence, but who has less than five years’ lawful residence in the UK and thus has only the lowest level of protection, the SSHD must surmount a ‘high threshold’. Secondly, … the judge apparently lost sight of the fact, clearly mentioned in the deportation decision letter against which the appeal was being brought, that Mr Barus was not simply a convicted drug dealer, but a convicted drug dealer who had trafficked in or had available firearms and ammunition.”
Lord Justice Bean, judgment, para. 33
These were, he said, “serious omissions in the balancing exercise”, and the Upper Tribunal’s decision upholding the first ruling “cannot be allowed to stand”. The court declined to decide for itself whether the deportation was lawful and sent the case back (judgment, paras. 33 and 34).
Deep dive: where the system broke down
RSN analysis. The “high threshold” language is the more significant error. EU free movement law builds in graduated protection: the longer an EU citizen has lived lawfully in the host country, the stronger the reasons needed to remove him. Regulation 27 reserves “serious grounds” for those with permanent residence and “imperative grounds” for those with ten years’ residence. A newcomer with under five years gets the baseline test. By describing even that baseline as a “high threshold”, the first tribunal effectively raised the bar for someone the law treated as least protected. The Court of Appeal has now said plainly that this is wrong.
The firearms point matters for a related reason. Schedule 1 to the 2016 Regulations, which tribunals must consider, says that the longer the sentence, “the greater the likelihood” that a person’s continued presence is a genuine, present and sufficiently serious threat. It counts tackling offences “related to the misuse of drugs” among the fundamental interests of society (judgment, paras. 24 to 26). A risk assessment that treats an armed drug trafficker as an unarmed one starts from the wrong facts.
The disclosure question shows a different weakness, and this one sits with the Home Office. The department’s own decision letter in January 2022 said Mr Barus had not declared his full criminal record. Yet the Upper Tribunal said the department did not appear to have made submissions on the point at the first hearing, and the Court of Appeal said it was never put to Mr Barus in cross-examination. Fairness requires that a witness be given the chance to answer an allegation of dishonesty before a judge relies on it. Because that never happened, the Court of Appeal held that the tribunal “cannot be criticised” for not treating the incomplete answer as evidence of deception (judgment, para. 32). In practical terms, the department lost the use of a key factual argument at the hearing where the facts were found.
Then there is delay. Mr Barus arrived in June 2019. Notice of liability to deportation came in August 2021. The first appeal was decided in May 2023. The Court of Appeal ruled in November 2026. A fresh Upper Tribunal hearing comes next, and either side may seek to appeal whatever that tribunal decides. Each year that passes adds to the residence, work history and family ties a tribunal is required to weigh under regulation 27(6). In that sense, delay can work in favour of the person resisting removal, whatever the merits.
The wider picture
The Home Office’s own figures put the case in context. In the year ending June 2026 there were 5,962 returns of foreign national offenders, up 12% on the previous year and “the highest observed since 2017”, according to official immigration statistics. EU nationals accounted for 52% of those returns.
Barus is not the first EU national whose deportation turned on rehabilitation under pre-Brexit rules. In February 2025 The Telegraph reported that an Upper Tribunal judge had allowed a Slovak man jailed for 15 months over a violent brawl involving shovels and metal bars to remain, saying his “rehabilitation appears to have been very successful”. The judge was quoted as noting that if the man offended again after Brexit, he would “not have the protection under EU law that he has benefited from on this occasion”.
The law on offending committed after Brexit is itself unsettled. The UK Supreme Court will hear Molnar and Vargova v Secretary of State for the Home Department on January 18 and 19, 2027. That case asks how the Withdrawal Agreement applies to people with settled status who face deportation for crimes committed after December 31, 2020, and whether an EU-law proportionality test still applies; the Court of Appeal held that it does not, as Free Movement summarised. Barus concerns the older, pre-Brexit regime, so it will not be decided by Molnar. Both cases test the same question: how much protection EU rules still give foreign offenders in Britain.
Oversight of offenders who remain in Britain is also under review. In September 2026 the Independent Chief Inspector of Borders and Immigration announced an inspection of the Home Office’s role in managing high-harm foreign national offenders in the community, focused on identification, oversight and information sharing. The inspectorate expects to report to the Home Secretary by January 2027.
RSN has previously reported on forged documents found in EU Settlement Scheme appeals and on a £7 million detention claim the High Court found dishonest. Readers following the longer story of Britain’s relationship with EU free movement may also revisit RSN’s 2016 pieces on falling public support for the European Union and the Brexit vote. Supporters of leaving argued that Parliament, rather than EU rules, should decide who could be removed from Britain. A decade later, cases like Barus are still being decided under those EU-derived rules.
Counter-arguments
There is a serious case on Mr Barus’s side, and the Court of Appeal did not reject it. The first tribunal heard live evidence from him, his partner and her daughter, and found “no reason to doubt” their relationship. It found that his relationships with his partner, her family and his wider family had been “protective factors that have reduced any risk of him re offending”. It accepted that he had complied with his release conditions in Slovakia and that there was no Police National Computer record of offending in Britain (judgment, para. 10, quoting the tribunal at paras. 63 to 68). The offences were committed well over a decade ago.
The governing law also cuts in his favour on some points. Regulation 27(5)(e) states that “a person’s previous criminal convictions do not in themselves justify the decision”. Schedule 1 says removal of someone who can show they have “successfully reformed or rehabilitated” is “less likely to be proportionate” (judgment, para. 25). A fresh tribunal, properly directed, could still conclude that Mr Barus poses no present threat.
On disclosure, the Court of Appeal said the “Drug-related offence” answer was misleading but “not entirely false”. In the Upper Tribunal, Mr Barus’s representative argued that the form asked only about offences within the 12 months before the application (judgment, para. 13, quoting the Upper Tribunal at para. 9). The Upper Tribunal did not need to decide that point, and the Court of Appeal did not address it.
In fairness to the Upper Tribunal, the Home Office asked it to decide only the narrow disclosure point, not the threshold and firearms errors that turned out to be decisive. Appeal judges are also generally reluctant to disturb findings by a judge who heard the witnesses. The Court of Appeal’s correction came on points of law, not on the first judge’s assessment of credibility.
What is established, disputed and not established
Established (by the judgment or official records):
- Mr Barus was convicted in Slovakia in March 2011 of drug-related and firearms offences and sentenced to 13 years. The Court of Appeal found the firearms element clear from the Slovak judgment, ACRO records and the Police National Computer.
- His EUSS application described his record only as a “Drug-related offence”, which the Court of Appeal called “misleading”.
- The First-tier Tribunal wrongly treated the test for a resident of under five years as a “high threshold” and, in the Court of Appeal’s words, “apparently lost sight of” the firearms element.
- The case has been remitted to a freshly constituted Upper Tribunal.
Disputed:
- Whether Mr Barus poses a genuine, present and sufficiently serious threat today. The first tribunal said no; that finding has been set aside, and a new tribunal must decide.
- Whether his incomplete answer on the application form was dishonest. That allegation was never put to him in cross-examination.
Not established:
- Whether Mr Barus will be deported. No court has yet decided that.
- Why the Home Office did not put the disclosure point to him at the 2023 hearing. The judgment does not say.
- How many other EU deportation appeals have been decided using a “high threshold” description for residents of under five years. RSN found no published figure.
What accountability would look like
- Clear guidance for tribunals. The tribunal judiciary should make sure judges hearing pre-Brexit EU deportation appeals apply the correct, graduated test, so the baseline level of protection is not described as a “high threshold”.
- Better Home Office case presentation. Where a decision letter relies on an applicant’s incomplete disclosure, Presenting Officers should be instructed to put that point to the appellant at the hearing. The Home Office should say whether it has reviewed what went wrong in this case.
- A timetable. Parliament’s Home Affairs Committee could ask the department how long EU deportation cases take from notice to final decision, and how many remain open from before 2022.
- Published outcomes. The Home Office could publish how many deportation decisions against EU nationals are overturned on appeal each year, and on what grounds.
- Follow-through from inspection. The Chief Inspector’s report on high-harm foreign national offenders, due to the Home Secretary by January 2027, should be published promptly with the Home Office’s response.
Sources: Court of Appeal, SSHD v Barus [2026] EWCA Civ 1447 (November 11, 2026); Courts and Tribunals Judiciary, hearing listing; Immigration (European Economic Area) Regulations 2016, regulation 27 and Schedule 1; Home Office, How many people are returned from the UK? (year ending June 2026); Independent Chief Inspector of Borders and Immigration, inspection announcement (September 2026); UK Supreme Court, Molnar v SSHD case page; Free Movement, case note and Supreme Court preview; The Telegraph via Yahoo News, “Slovakian jailed over shovel attack allowed to stay in UK” (February 17, 2025).
Featured image: Royal Courts of Justice main gate, London, home of the Court of Appeal, by David Castor, released into the public domain (CC0) via Wikimedia Commons.
How this article was made: Right Side News researched and drafted this article with the help of AI tools. Sources are linked so readers can check them. Spot an error? Tell us in the comments and we will correct it.
