Democrats will hold at least 55 Senate seats in January. Republicans are trying to confirm about two dozen judges first, and their early 2028 favorites, JD Vance and Marco Rubio, have not said whether they will run.
Two weeks after the Nov. 3 midterms, Senate Republicans have two problems: a short calendar now and a hard map later. Democrats flipped at least eight Republican-held Senate seats, enough to take control of the chamber when the new Congress convenes on Jan. 3, 2027. Vice President JD Vance, who led the first national poll of the 2028 Republican field taken after the midterms, told Fox News on Nov. 16 that he has not decided whether to run. “We’ll figure it out sometime next year,” he said.
Coverage of the 2028 race so far has mostly been a horse race between Vance and Secretary of State Marco Rubio. Less attention has gone to the Senate itself, which confirms judges, Cabinet officers and any Supreme Court justice. A Republican president elected in 2028 could face a Democratic Senate, and Republican senators are saying openly that the 2028 Senate map makes that likely.
Where the Senate count stands
Before the election, Republicans held a 53-47 majority (the 47 includes two independents who caucus with Democrats). CBS News projected Democratic pickups in seven states on election night: James Talarico over Ken Paxton in Texas, Annie Andrews in South Carolina, Adam Hamilton over Sen. Roger Marshall in Kansas, Troy Jackson over Sen. Susan Collins in Maine, Josh Turek in Iowa, Sherrod Brown over Sen. Jon Husted in Ohio, and Roy Cooper in North Carolina (CBS News live results). RSN covered the Texas result in an earlier analysis of the Talarico race.
Mississippi became the eighth flip on Nov. 11, when the Associated Press called the race for Democrat Scott Colom, who led Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith by 4,669 votes at the time of the call. Hyde-Smith conceded in a video on X: “I respect the decision of Mississippi voters” (MS NOW). RSN followed the late count in its report on late-count races. That brings Democrats to 55 seats.
Alaska is still open. In the latest update reported by Alaska Public Media, Democrat Mary Peltola had 49.98 percent of first-choice votes to Sen. Dan Sullivan’s 45.93 percent. Because she is under 50 percent, the state is expected to run its ranked-choice tabulation on Nov. 18, with certification on Nov. 25. The AP has not called the race. If Peltola wins, the Senate will be 56-44.
The lame-duck race to confirm judges
Confirmations are where the loss shows up first. Ballotpedia counts 56 Article III judges confirmed in President Trump’s second term through Nov. 1, 2026. That is the third-highest total among presidents since Bill Clinton at the same point in a second term. The appeals-court count, 10, is the lowest. The median for appellate judges at this stage is 18, and Barack Obama had 23.
Republicans now want to fill as many remaining seats as they can before January. According to The New York Times (as republished by GV Wire), aides say up to 25 judicial nominees are in the pipeline, four for appeals courts and 21 for district courts. Majority Leader John Thune said: “We’re going to make the most of the time that we’ve got.” CBS News, in a report republished by Yahoo, put the second-term total at 57 by Nov. 11, with 28 current and 15 announced future vacancies.
Democrats cannot block these votes. Since a Nov. 21, 2013 precedent, cloture on most presidential nominations has required only a simple majority, and the Times notes that a 60-vote threshold no longer applies to judicial nominations. RSN’s own archive recorded the fight at the time: “The Democrats’ Threat to ‘Go Nuclear’” (July 2013) and “Why Reid’s Power Grab Is a Progressive Victory” (November 2013). Republicans are now using the precedent Democrats set under Majority Leader Harry Reid. Democrats can still force procedural votes and use up floor time. Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.) told the Times, “We should spare no effort to stop judges who will be on the bench long after we are gone.”
The bigger risk to the push is Republican disagreement. Sen. John Cornyn (R-Texas) objected that Elliott Gaiser, nominated to the Northern District of Texas, did not go through the review process he and Sen. Ted Cruz set up, and said of Gaiser, “I will look at his record and make a decision.” Judiciary Chairman Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) defended the committee’s pace. Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.), expected to lead the committee next year, has called for “a hard reset on the nominations process next Congress,” according to CBS.
What a Democratic Senate means for nominations
From January, the majority leader will decide which nominations reach the floor, and Democrats will chair the committees that hold hearings. On election night, CBS News wrote that if Republicans lost the Senate, “their efforts to confirm the president’s executive and judicial branch nominees will come to a standstill.” That applies to any Cabinet replacement in 2027 or 2028, not only judges.
The Supreme Court is the open question. No justice has announced a retirement. LifeNews reported that Justice Samuel Alito has indicated he intends to stay through the current term, and that Thune told Punchbowl News in June that Republicans were “prepared if it should happen” and would make a lame-duck confirmation “the top priority.” The precedent both parties remember is 2016: the Senate’s own record of Supreme Court nominations lists Merrick Garland, nominated March 16, 2016, with no action taken by the Republican Senate. RSN analysis: a vacancy that opens after Jan. 3 would test whether a Democratic majority applies the same rule to a Republican president. Nothing in the record yet tells us how it would act.
The 2028 Senate map
Republican senators are not hiding their pessimism. Speaking to Fox News Digital on Nov. 12, Sen. Bernie Moreno (R-Ohio), the Senate GOP campaign chief, said: “Look, it is an absolutely brutal map, but, politics, things change pretty quickly.” Sen. Steve Daines (R-Mont.) said, “I think this will take a few cycles before we’ll probably get back to the majority.” Sen. Thom Tillis (R-N.C.) was blunter: “I don’t see any pickups.”
NBC News’s early look at the 2028 map (Nov. 16) explains why. Republicans will defend Wisconsin and North Carolina, the core battlegrounds, plus Iowa, Kansas, South Carolina, Alaska and Florida. In Florida, Sen. Ashley Moody won this year’s special election by less than 3 points and must run again in 2028. NBC says the GOP “would need to pick up at least six seats to flip control of the chamber in 2028,” or seven without the vice presidency. That count assumes a 56-44 Senate. If Sullivan wins in Alaska, the target drops by one.
Democrats have exposed seats too. NBC lists Arizona, Nevada, Georgia and Pennsylvania as core battlegrounds, plus New Hampshire and Ohio. Ohio is the best Republican target: Trump carried it by 11 points in 2024, and Brown won this year’s special election by about 5 points, so the seat is on the ballot again in 2028. NBC calls it “the only double-digit Trump state represented by a Democrat in the next cycle.”
The Republican bench
The first national poll taken after the midterms is the Economist/YouGov survey of Nov. 9-11. It asked intended primary voters an open-ended question, with answers coded by YouGov using an AI model. Among Republican primary voters, Vance led with 40 percent, Rubio had 33 percent and Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis 14 percent. Nine percent named Trump, who is barred from a third elected term by the 22nd Amendment. Nikki Haley and Rep. Thomas Massie each had 1 percent. YouGov’s summary does not give the sample size for this question.
The same poll shows a weakness in the general electorate. Overall, 39 percent said they would definitely or probably vote for the Democratic candidate in 2028, against 31 percent for the Republican. Independents favored the Democrat 28 percent to 14 percent. Among Republicans who do not call themselves MAGA supporters, only 46 percent said they would definitely vote Republican, compared with 85 percent of MAGA Republicans.
Vance. On record, he has said only that he will decide next year, and that “when I make a decision, I will be all in on whatever that decision is” (CNBC). He said Republicans were “shellacked” in the midterms and urged the party to double down on “economic nationalism.” CNBC reports that he has blamed the Iran war for the outcome. Two reports about his plans rest on unnamed sources and point in different directions. Reuters, citing anonymous sources as relayed by CNBC, reported that Vance had begun early preparations for a run. CNN, citing unnamed people close to him, reported on Nov. 13 that he has seriously considered not running. Neither report names its sources, RSN has found no independent confirmation of either, and Vance has said publicly only that he has not decided.
Rubio. In a September interview with Colombian broadcaster RCN, translated by NBC News and reported by The Hill, Rubio said: “I don’t know what the future holds, but I have no plans at this time.” He added: “I’m not a candidate for anything right now.” The same report quoted an unnamed person familiar with the matter who told NBC that Rubio has no intention of running in 2028. That claim is not on the record and has not been independently confirmed. Rubio’s own words leave the door open.
DeSantis is a distant third in the YouGov poll but does better among non-MAGA Republican primary voters (19 percent) than among MAGA supporters (10 percent). He has not announced a decision.
The case against reading too much into November
Republican senators argue that a bad midterm does not settle the next presidential race. Thune pointed to his own party’s history, recalling for Fox that Republicans once talked of reaching 60 seats: “And by 2006, we were back in the minority.” He added that “the map matters for sure, but the mood of the country also really matters.” Daines argued that Democrats “can’t help themselves, but they’ll overreach in the next couple of years.” That is a prediction, not evidence, but it is the main argument Republican strategists are making.
Polls taken two years early also have a poor record. The YouGov question was open-ended and coded by AI, Rubio says he is not a candidate, and Vance says he has not decided. Ranked lists of a field with no declared candidates measure name recognition as much as preference. And the Senate math depends on one uncalled race in Alaska. RSN covered how Thune kept his leadership post after the election in an earlier report.
What is established, disputed and not established
Established:
- Democrats flipped at least eight Republican Senate seats and will hold at least 55 seats from Jan. 3, 2027. The AP called Mississippi for Colom on Nov. 11, and Hyde-Smith conceded.
- Trump has had 56 Article III judges confirmed through Nov. 1, including 10 for the appeals courts (Ballotpedia).
- Most nominations need only a simple majority for cloture under the 2013 precedent, so Senate Republicans can confirm nominees through Jan. 3 if they hold their own votes.
- Vance said on Nov. 16 that he will decide on 2028 “sometime next year.” Rubio said in September that he has “no plans at this time.”
- Moreno, Daines and Tillis described the 2028 map as difficult in on-record interviews.
Disputed or unresolved:
- The Alaska Senate race. Peltola leads on first choices; the ranked-choice tabulation is set for Nov. 18 and certification for Nov. 25.
- How many of the roughly 25 pending judicial nominees will be confirmed before January, given objections such as Cornyn’s.
- The exact second-term judge count, which is 56 or 57 in the sources cited here because confirmations are still under way.
Not established:
- Whether Vance has begun preparing a campaign (Reuters, unnamed sources) or has considered not running (CNN, unnamed sources). Neither has been independently confirmed.
- That Rubio privately intends not to run, which rests on a single unnamed source quoted by NBC.
- Any Supreme Court vacancy. No justice has announced a retirement.
- How a Democratic Senate will treat Trump’s nominees after January. Whitehouse’s call for a “hard reset” is a statement of intent, not a rule.
RSN analysis: The lame-duck weeks matter more for the judiciary than the 2028 primary does for now. Judges confirmed by Jan. 3 serve for life. Any Republican who wins the White House in 2028 may need Democratic votes to staff the government, and the field’s two leaders have not committed to running. Republicans who want a 2029 Senate majority will have to win in Ohio and hold Iowa, Kansas and the Carolinas, the same kinds of states they lost this month.
Sources: CBS News live results; MS NOW on the Mississippi call; Alaska Public Media; Ballotpedia; The New York Times via GV Wire; CBS News via Yahoo; Congressional Research Service, R43331; U.S. Senate, Supreme Court nominations; LifeNews; Fox News; NBC News; Economist/YouGov; CNBC; The Hill via Yahoo; National Archives, 22nd Amendment.
Featured image: Iowa State Capitol, Des Moines, by Paul R. Burley, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
How this article was made: Right Side News researched and drafted this article with the help of AI tools. Sources are linked so readers can check them. Spot an error? Tell us in the comments and we will correct it.
