Home » Editorial » Democratic Trifectas in Five States Could Push Popular Vote Compact Past 270

Democratic Trifectas in Five States Could Push Popular Vote Compact Past 270

The National Popular Vote compact is 48 electoral votes short. Five new Democratic trifectas hold 61. The math, the 2028 deadline and the legal fight.

The green-tiled dome of the Pennsylvania State Capitol in Harrisburg rising behind the rear plaza, fountain and flagpoles

The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact sits 48 electoral votes short of taking effect. Democrats now hold full control of five states that have not joined it, worth 61 electoral votes. Whether that becomes a new way of electing the president in 2028 depends on four statehouses and, almost certainly, the Supreme Court.

For twenty years, the plan to route around the Electoral College without amending the Constitution has stalled short of its goal. The November 3 midterm results changed the arithmetic. According to Ballotpedia, Democrats won six new state government trifectas, meaning control of the governorship and both legislative chambers. Five of those states, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Arizona, Wisconsin and Nevada, have not adopted the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. Together they hold 61 electoral votes. The compact needs 48 more to take effect.

If enough of those states sign on before July 20, 2028, the states that have joined would be bound to give their electors to whichever presidential ticket wins the most votes nationwide, regardless of how their own voters cast their ballots. The legal fight that would follow is one that scholars on both sides say is coming, and nobody can confidently predict how it ends.

What most coverage leaves out

Most reporting since the election has framed the compact as a Democratic project that Republicans can no longer block in the states. That is accurate as far as it goes. Ballotpedia found that 16 of the 18 member states had Democratic trifectas when they enacted it. Less attention goes to three features of the compact’s own text that matter more than its partisan history.

First, a member state cannot leave in the middle of an election. The compact’s text says a withdrawal made “six months or less before the end of a President’s term shall not become effective until a President or Vice President shall have been qualified to serve the next term.” Because terms end on January 20, the effective cutoff is July 20 of the election year. After that date, a legislature that dislikes the national result has no way out until the next term begins.

Second, the compact asks each member state to accept other states’ counts without question. Article III directs each member state’s chief election official to “treat as conclusive an official statement containing the number of popular votes in a state for each presidential slate.” A state that disagreed with how another state handled late mail ballots, a recount or a court-ordered extension would be required to accept that state’s certified number anyway. The compact contains no procedure for a national recount.

Third, the compact is not a guaranteed partisan advantage. In 2024, President Trump won the national popular vote, according to the Federal Election Commission’s official results. Had the compact been in force, California’s 54 electors, New York’s 28 and Illinois’s 19 would have gone to Trump. RSN’s analysis: the strongest conservative objection to the compact is about federalism and legal stability, not about which party it would help in a given year. Patrick Rosenstiel, a Minnesota Republican strategist who consults for the National Popular Vote campaign, has made the same point from the other side, telling the Associated Press the idea is not inherently partisan. The AP noted that Republican-majority chambers, including the Oklahoma Senate, have passed compact bills that went no further.

Background: a compact instead of an amendment

The Constitution leaves the method of choosing electors to the states. Article II, Section 1 says each state “shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of Electors.” Every state now holds a popular vote and, except for Maine and Nebraska, gives all its electors to the statewide winner. That winner-take-all practice is state law, not a constitutional requirement.

The Electoral College itself was one of the compromises of the 1787 Convention, balancing the large and small states and the national and federal character of the new government. Alexander Hamilton defended it in Federalist No. 68, writing that the method of choosing the president was “almost the only part of the system, of any consequence, which has escaped without severe censure,” and that “if the manner of it be not perfect, it is at least excellent.”

The modern campaign against it traces to 2000. A Congressional Research Service (CRS) summary notes that George W. Bush won 271 electoral votes while Al Gore received 537,209 more popular votes, and that in 2016 Donald Trump won 304 electoral votes while Hillary Clinton received 2,869,686 more popular votes. The compact was introduced in 2006 by National Popular Vote Inc., a California nonprofit, and states began joining in 2007. Amending the Constitution would require two-thirds of both houses of Congress and three-quarters of the states. The compact needs only states holding 270 of the 538 electoral votes.

Progress was slow for years. The CRS counted 196 electoral votes in October 2019. The most recent addition came in April 2026, when Virginia Governor Abigail Spanberger signed the state into the compact after Democrats won the governorship and full control of the General Assembly in 2025, NPR reported. That brought the total to 18 states plus the District of Columbia and 222 electoral votes, a figure the National Popular Vote organization confirms on its site.

The deep dive: the arithmetic and the five states

The six new Democratic trifectas named by the AP are Arizona, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin, worth 71 electoral votes. Minnesota, with 10, already joined in 2023. The remaining five carry the following electoral votes under the 2020 census apportionment:

  • Pennsylvania: 19
  • Michigan: 15
  • Arizona: 11
  • Wisconsin: 10
  • Nevada: 6

All five would bring the compact to 283. RSN checked the combinations. Without Pennsylvania, the other four reach only 264; without Michigan, 268. Any four that include both Pennsylvania and Michigan clear 270. In practice, Pennsylvania and Michigan are both required, plus at least two of Arizona, Wisconsin and Nevada. That matches the assessments by Ballotpedia and Votebeat.

The public statements so far are uneven. Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro, widely seen as a possible 2028 presidential candidate, said on a podcast, as the AP reported, “I think that the national popular vote makes sense. My views on that have not changed.” Wisconsin Governor-elect David Crowley said of the Electoral College, “We can do away with it,” and that he is “interested in having those conversations with the state Legislature.” Wisconsin state Sen. Kelda Roys told Ballotpedia that “National popular vote will be something that we’ll prioritize early in the session.” In Arizona, incoming Senate President Priya Sundareshan said, “We certainly are and have been prepared to join the compact.” Michigan’s incoming Senate majority leader, Darrin Camilleri, has argued that “Other states that have done this are not going to be the tipping-point states.”

The governors who would have to sign the bills are more guarded. According to the AP, Arizona Governor Katie Hobbs declined to say whether she favors joining and said she is focused on the cost of living. Michigan Governor-elect Jocelyn Benson’s office would not comment. A spokesman for Nevada Governor-elect Aaron Ford said, “There will be a time to talk about presidential elections.” Nevada is the one state of the five where a Democratic governor has already said no: in 2019, then-Governor Steve Sisolak vetoed a compact bill, writing that it “could diminish the role of smaller states like Nevada.”

Timing is the other constraint. Compact legislation was introduced in all five states in 2025 or 2026, Ballotpedia reports, and the National Popular Vote campaign says it has sponsors lined up for the new sessions that open in January 2027. Under Article III, the compact governs any presidential election in a year when it is “on July 20, in effect” in states holding a majority of electoral votes. To control the 2028 election, the bills would have to be enacted and in force by July 20, 2028.

The constitutional fight ahead

The legal questions are real, and they cut in more than one direction.

The Compact Clause. Article I, Section 10 provides that “No State shall, without the Consent of Congress, … enter into any Agreement or Compact with another State.” Congress has not consented to this one. The Supreme Court held in Virginia v. Tennessee (1893) and U.S. Steel Corp. v. Multistate Tax Commission (1978) that consent is needed only for compacts that increase state power at the expense of federal supremacy. Supporters say the compact does no such thing because choosing electors is already a state power. Critics, including the Heritage Foundation, argue that a compact designed to change how the nation chooses its president is exactly the kind of agreement the clause was written to check.

State power over electors. Supporters lean on Chiafalo v. Washington (2020), in which the Court unanimously upheld state laws binding electors to their pledges and said Article II “gives the States far-reaching authority over presidential electors.” That ruling did not address the compact, and scholars disagree on how far it reaches.

Equal protection and other states’ rules. Notre Dame law professor Derek Muller told the AP that states may run their own elections but cannot set rules that determine outcomes in other states’ contests. Ballots differ by state, and some third-party candidates appear in some states and not others, which could raise Fourteenth Amendment equal protection claims. “I think the Supreme Court will be interested,” Muller said. University of Kentucky election law professor Josh Douglas told Votebeat, “If this does get enough states to put it into force, I think everyone agrees that it will end up in litigation,” and called the outcome “a close call.”

RSN’s analysis: the timetable itself is a risk. If the compact reaches 270 in the spring of 2028, any challenge would have to move from filing to a final Supreme Court ruling in the months before ballots are cast. A ruling in the fall, or a dispute that first arises after a close November count, would test the system at the worst possible moment.

The case for the compact

Supporters’ arguments deserve a fair hearing. Four presidential elections, 1876, 1888, 2000 and 2016, produced an Electoral College winner who lost the national popular vote, Votebeat notes. Alyssa Cass, a strategist for the National Popular Vote campaign, told NPR that “The votes of 4 out of 5 Americans who live in safely blue or safely red states are essentially irrelevant,” because campaigns spend their time and money in a handful of battleground states. Proponents argue, as the CRS summarizes, that candidates “would campaign more widely” and pay more attention to the rest of the country. On the legal question, they point to the plain text of Article II, which lets each legislature direct the manner of appointment.

Opponents answer that the compact would let a state’s electors be chosen against the expressed will of its own voters. Wisconsin Assembly Republican leader Tyler August said the change would “undermine that balance and disenfranchise Wisconsin voters,” according to the AP. Analysts at the America First Policy Institute wrote in September that it “disenfranchises voters in member states if enacted, violates the United States Constitution.” The CRS lists the other core objections: that the compact would diminish the role of the states, sidestep the amendment process the founders designed and “might lead to more, rather than fewer, disputed elections.”

Political will is also uncertain. Michigan had a Democratic trifecta in 2023 and 2024 and did not adopt the compact, Ballotpedia notes. Muller told the AP that some lawmakers may have second thoughts now that the proposal is a real possibility rather than a symbolic protest. Votebeat put it plainly: “Those last few votes, though, were always going to be an uphill battle.”

What is established, disputed and not established

Established: The compact has 18 member states plus the District of Columbia with 222 electoral votes, and takes effect only at 270. Virginia joined in April 2026. Democrats won new trifectas in Arizona, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin on November 3. The five non-member states among them hold 61 electoral votes, enough to reach 283. Pennsylvania and Michigan are both needed to cross 270. The compact applies to a presidential election only if it is in effect on July 20 of that year, and bars withdrawal in the final six months of a term.

Disputed: Whether the compact needs the consent of Congress under the Compact Clause; whether it violates equal protection by combining votes cast under different state rules; and whether it would produce better or worse outcomes for campaigns, recounts and voter confidence. Legal scholars disagree on each, and no court has ruled.

Not established: That any of the five legislatures will pass the compact, or that Governors Hobbs, Benson or Ford would sign it; none of the three has publicly committed. It is also not established that the compact would be in force for 2028 or would survive in court. Nor would the compact abolish the Electoral College, which remains in the Constitution; it would change only how member states appoint their electors.

What it means

RSN’s analysis: the midterms have turned a long-running advocacy campaign into a live question for 2027 legislative sessions. The decision now rests with a small number of state lawmakers and governors, not with the voters whose electors would follow the national tally instead of their own. A change of this size has historically come through the amendment process, which forces a national consensus. The compact’s backers chose a path designed to avoid that requirement. Whatever one thinks of the Electoral College, the honest route to replacing it remains Article V, and the coming litigation will decide whether the shortcut is lawful.

RSN has covered the post-midterm landscape in detail, including the late-count reversals in North Carolina and Mississippi, John Thune’s re-election as Senate Republican leader and the fate of the SAVE Act, and what the Texas Senate result says about Latino voters. In 2016, RSN argued that eliminating the Electoral College was the real goal behind post-election protests.

Sources: Associated Press via PBS NewsHour (Nov. 10, 2026); Ballotpedia News (Nov. 11, 2026); Votebeat (Nov. 16, 2026); NPR via WUNC (Apr. 14, 2026); compact text and status page, National Popular Vote; Congressional Research Service, IF11191 (Oct. 29, 2019); U.S. Constitution, Art. II and Art. I; Chiafalo v. Washington; Virginia v. Tennessee; U.S. Steel Corp. v. Multistate Tax Commission; Federalist No. 68; Heritage Foundation; Federal Election Commission.

Image: Pennsylvania State Capitol, Harrisburg. Photo by w_lemay, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.


How this article was made: Right Side News researched and drafted this article with the help of AI tools. Sources are linked so readers can check them. Spot an error? Tell us in the comments and we will correct it.

Sponsored

The Week in Review

One email every Sunday: the week’s rulings, reports and the documents behind them.