California did not lose a trial. It signed a stipulation. On November 17, 2026, a federal judge in Los Angeles turned that agreement into a permanent injunction that bars the state from enforcing its 2025 mask ban and badge-display law against any federal officer, and it reaches further than any ruling the state had actually lost.
A year to the day after the Justice Department sued, U.S. District Judge Christina A. Snyder of the Central District of California signed a two-page order entering permanent injunction and dismissing action in United States v. State of California, No. 2:25-cv-10999. The order bars California, Governor Gavin Newsom, Attorney General Rob Bonta and their successors from enforcing four statutory sections “against the United States, federal law enforcement officers, and federal law enforcement agencies.” The case is dismissed with prejudice, and the court keeps jurisdiction to enforce the judgment.
The four sections are the operative parts of two laws Newsom signed on September 20, 2025: the No Secret Police Act (Senate Bill 627), which banned most officers from wearing face coverings that conceal their identity, and the No Vigilantes Act (Senate Bill 805), which required non-uniformed officers to display their agency and a name or badge number. Both laws expressly reached federal officers. California enacted them in response to what the Ninth Circuit, quoting the No Vigilantes Act, called the federal government’s “broad immigration enforcement efforts,” after a summer of raids by agents who wore masks and did not display badges.
The order opens with the words that explain how it came about: “Upon consideration of the joint stipulation in this case filed by Plaintiff the United States of America; and Defendants the State of California, Attorney General Rob Bonta, and Governor Gavin Newsom.” California agreed to be enjoined.
What most coverage missed
The Justice Department’s November 19 press release describes the injunction as entered “as part of a final resolution” of the lawsuit. That is accurate, but it does not use the word stipulation. Most headlines presented the outcome as a judge’s ruling against the state. The court order itself shows a consent judgment, and that distinction matters for three reasons.
First, the judgment is broader than anything California lost in court. The order enjoins Sections 7288 and 7289 of the California Government Code, the provisions that require every law enforcement agency “operating in California,” federal agencies included, to adopt and publicly post written policies on identification and on face coverings. At the preliminary-injunction stage, Judge Snyder had ruled that the United States lacked Article III standing to challenge those policy provisions, according to the Ninth Circuit’s October 14, 2026 opinion summarizing the district court’s rulings. The federal government did not appeal that point. California has now agreed not to enforce those provisions against federal agencies anyway.
Second, there is no merits judgment. In a filing reported by the Sacramento Bee, the state’s lawyers said officials “continue to dispute” the federal government’s claims. A consent decree settles the case without a trial court finding on the facts, so the published law on the subject comes from the Ninth Circuit’s preliminary-injunction opinions rather than a final district court decision.
Third, some of the wire coverage got the basic facts backward. The Sacramento Bee story syndicated on Yahoo News said the No Vigilantes Act “banned federal officers from wearing face masks” and the No Secret Police Act “required federal agents to wear identification.” The statutes, and both Ninth Circuit opinions, show the reverse. The same story said the Ninth Circuit had ruled that “the two laws” violated the Supremacy Clause. The appeals court ruled on one section of one law.
Background: two laws, one lawsuit
The Justice Department filed its complaint on November 17, 2025. Then-Attorney General Pam Bondi said the laws “discriminate against the federal government and are designed to create risk for our agents,” and added: “These laws cannot stand.” Bill Essayli, First Assistant U.S. Attorney for the Central District, said: “Unconstitutional laws such as this one further endanger our brave men and women protecting our community.”
On February 9, 2026, Judge Snyder, an appointee of President Bill Clinton, split the difference. As Reuters reported, she preliminarily enjoined the mask ban as applied to federal officers but left the identification law in force. On the mask ban, she found the law “unlawfully discriminates against the federal government in violation of the intergovernmental immunity doctrine,” as the Ninth Circuit later quoted her. The problem was the law’s own text: it exempted California’s state officers, including the California Highway Patrol, while binding federal agents.
On the identification law, she found the United States “ha[d] not met its burden to show that enforcement of the challenged provisions . . . would interfere with or take control of federal law enforcement operations.” Newsom called that part of the ruling “a clear win for the rule of law” and said “no badge and no name mean no accountability.” Bondi called the mask ruling “ANOTHER key court victory.”
California did not appeal the mask-ban ruling, the Ninth Circuit noted. The United States appealed only the denial on Section 10 of the No Vigilantes Act, codified at California Penal Code Section 13654.
Deep dive: what the Ninth Circuit actually held
The appeal went to a panel of Judges Jacqueline H. Nguyen, Mark J. Bennett and Daniel P. Collins. The panel entered a temporary administrative injunction on February 19, 2026, and on April 22 granted an injunction pending appeal in a published order written by Judge Bennett. “The district court asked the wrong question,” the panel wrote. The October 14 opinion, also by Judge Bennett and with no separate concurrence or dissent, reversed the denial and remanded “with instructions to enter a preliminary injunction.”
The heart of the opinion is a distinction between two strands of intergovernmental immunity. A state may sometimes regulate federal contractors, and courts then ask how heavily the rule burdens federal work. A state may not directly regulate the federal government itself. The panel defined the second category this way: “a direct regulation regulates the government qua government; it controls how the government conducts specifically governmental functions.”
Section 10, the court found, fell squarely in that category. “Section 10 explicitly overrides the federal government’s power to determine whether, how, and when to publicly identify its officers,” Judge Bennett wrote. Because the law applies by its terms to “any federal law enforcement officer,” it “lay[] hold of” federal agents in the language of the Supreme Court’s 1920 decision in Johnson v. Maryland.
That framing made the trial court’s inquiry beside the point. Judge Snyder had asked whether the United States had shown that its identification practices were “essential to federal law enforcement operations.” The panel answered that “the burden of the regulation on federal operations, whether substantial or otherwise, is irrelevant because, as discussed, there is no de minimis exception to the United States’s immunity from direct regulation.” It went further than the usual preliminary-injunction language: “we conclude that the United States is certain to succeed.”
The court also rejected the argument that the law was harmless because it mirrored ordinary rules like traffic laws. Johnson v. Maryland had suggested states might impose general rules “regulating the mode of turning at the corners of streets,” the panel acknowledged. “But the Court has never relied on that distinction to uphold a State’s direct regulation of federal functions performed by federal officers,” it added. Section 10, unlike a traffic law, “applies exclusively to law enforcement officials and exclusively to their performance of law enforcement operations.”
One passage limits the practical stakes of the dispute. The panel noted that, regardless of the injunction, “an individual officer would be entitled to a Supremacy Clause defense against any prosecution brought under the statute.” Under Section 10, a “willful and knowing violation” was punishable as a misdemeanor. The injunction removes the threat of state prosecution of federal officers under the listed sections. It does not change any federal rule on masks or identification.
What Section 10 required
The identification law was not a blanket rule. Penal Code Section 13654 required a “law enforcement officer operating in California that is not uniformed” to “visibly display identification that includes their agency and either a name or badge number or both name and badge number when performing their enforcement duties.” Enforcement duties meant “active and planned operations involving the arrest or detention of an individual, or deployment for crowd control purposes.”
It carried six exceptions: undercover and investigative work; plainclothes operations by listed state agencies or their “federal equivalents”; protective equipment that prevents display; exigent circumstances; Special Weapons and Tactics (SWAT) and tactical units; and protective details for officials and judges. It also contained a safe harbor. An agency that adopted and posted its own written identification policy under Government Code Section 7288 was exempt from the criminal provision. For federal agencies, the Ninth Circuit observed in April, that meant a choice between writing California’s policy into their own rules or exposing their officers to prosecution.
Counter-arguments
The case for the California laws deserves a fair statement. Supporters argued that masked, unbadged agents made it impossible for residents to tell a lawful arrest from a kidnapping. “It’s problematic when Californians can’t tell the difference between a law enforcement officer who is charged with protecting them and a criminal who is attempting to cause them harm,” Bonta said in 2025, as quoted by the Sacramento Bee. That concern is not partisan. Impersonation of officers is a real crime, and visible identification has long been the norm for uniformed police.
The federal response is that agents have faced harassment and the online publication of their home addresses. The Justice Department’s release said officers “have faced an unprecedented wave of harassment, doxxing, and even violence.” Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward, Jr. said the injunction “confirms a basic constitutional principle: states do not have the authority to regulate the Federal Government or dictate how federal law enforcement officers perform their official duties.” Acting Assistant Attorney General Jonathan D. Guynn of the Civil Division added: “The Federal Government, not the states, gets to decide what equipment federal officers may use and what measures they may take to protect themselves while performing their official duties.”
There is also a scholarly critique of the reasoning, if not the result. University of California, Davis law professor Vikram David Amar, writing in Justia’s Verdict, agreed that the panel correctly rejected the trial court’s burden test. He argued, though, that its treatment of the Johnson v. Maryland traffic-law example was weak, since the Maryland driver’s license requirement in that case was itself struck down, and he suggested that historical practice may be a better guide to which state rules federal officers must obey.
Right Side News (RSN) analysis: the strongest point on California’s side is about accountability, not federalism. The Supremacy Clause answer settles who may set the rule. It does not answer whether there should be one. Congress has the power to require federal officers to carry visible identification, and so do the agencies themselves. Neither question was before the court.
The 2026 replacement law
California legislators anticipated losing. State Sen. Scott Wiener, the author of the original mask ban, introduced Senate Bill 1004 (SB 1004) to remove the exemption for state officers, a move Fox 11 Los Angeles reported was aimed at curing the discrimination problem Judge Snyder identified. The Sacramento Bee describes SB 1004 as “the 2026 version” and reports that it requires state and local agencies to develop and display mask policies. Wiener said it followed “clear guidance from a federal judge for how to move forward.”
The Bee also reported that because the injunction bars enforcement of the underlying code sections “without distinguishing the new wording, the new law’s fate was not immediately clear.” RSN could not independently confirm SB 1004’s final enactment status or which code sections it amends.
RSN’s analysis: even if a universal mask ban cures the discrimination defect, the Ninth Circuit’s direct-regulation holding has no exception for evenhanded laws. The panel quoted its own precedent that a state law that “directly regulates the conduct of the federal government or discriminates against it is invalid, even if it is no more restrictive than federal law.” A neutral mask ban that names federal officers would face the same objection Section 10 did. The stipulated injunction, which binds the state’s successors, makes that argument moot for the sections it lists.
The national picture
California is one front in a wider campaign. The Justice Department has filed similar suits against Connecticut, over a law that also sought to impose state use-of-force policies on federal officers, and against the City and County of Denver, over a local masking and identification ordinance. The department lists Maryland, New York, Virginia, New Jersey, Philadelphia and Milwaukee among other targets of its Civil Division litigation.
Those cases will not all go the same way. The Ninth Circuit opinion binds federal courts in California and the other western states in that circuit. Connecticut sits in the Second Circuit and Colorado in the Tenth. The Justice Department does not win everything, either: this month RSN reported that a federal judge in Pennsylvania had dismissed the department’s challenge to Philadelphia’s policy on Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detainers, finding that local cooperation with detainers is voluntary. The difference is the one the Ninth Circuit drew: a state may decline to help federal agents, but it may not direct how they do their work. RSN has covered that line between state refusal and state interference for years, from the federal supremacy debate of 2014 to the sanctuary-jurisdiction fights that followed the 2016 election.
What is established, disputed and not established
Established (from court records):
- Judge Snyder signed the order on November 17, 2026, exactly one year after the complaint was filed on November 17, 2025 (order, Document 90).
- The order rests on a joint stipulation of both parties, dismisses the case with prejudice, and enjoins Government Code Sections 7288 and 7289 and Penal Code Sections 185.5 and 13654 as applied to federal officers and agencies.
- On October 14, 2026, a three-judge Ninth Circuit panel, without dissent, reversed the denial of a preliminary injunction on the identification law and held the United States “certain to succeed” on its direct-regulation claim.
- The February 2026 preliminary injunction against the mask ban rested on discrimination, because the law exempted state officers. California did not appeal it.
Disputed:
- California says it continues to dispute that the laws were unconstitutional or endangered agents, according to its filing as reported by the Sacramento Bee.
- Whether masking is necessary for officer safety, or mainly shields officers from accountability, remains contested and was never tried.
Not established:
- Why California agreed to enjoin the written-policy provisions that the trial court had said the United States lacked standing to challenge. Neither party has publicly explained it.
- Whether SB 1004 is in force, which sections it amends, and whether it falls within this injunction.
- Whether California will seek further review of the Ninth Circuit’s published opinions. RSN found no report of an appeal or petition.
What accountability would look like
- California: the Attorney General’s office should explain publicly why the state stipulated to a judgment broader than the rulings against it, and whether it believes SB 1004 survives the injunction.
- The Justice Department: post the joint stipulation alongside the order, so the public can see exactly what each side agreed to.
- Congress: if visible identification of federal officers is a legitimate concern, the constitutional route runs through federal law. Lawmakers can set a national standard with clear exceptions for undercover and protective work, rather than leave it to fifty state legislatures.
- The Department of Homeland Security: publish its own written policy on when officers may cover their faces and when they must display an agency name and badge number, so residents can tell a lawful operation from an impersonator.
- The courts: the Connecticut and Denver cases, in the Second and Tenth Circuits, should be watched for a split with the Ninth Circuit’s no-de-minimis rule, which could send the question to the Supreme Court.
Sources: Order Entering Permanent Injunction, C.D. Cal. No. 2:25-cv-10999, Doc. 90 (Nov. 17, 2026); Ninth Circuit opinion, No. 26-926 (Oct. 14, 2026); Ninth Circuit order granting injunction pending appeal (Apr. 22, 2026); Justice Department press release 26-1386 (Nov. 19, 2026); Justice Department complaint release (Nov. 17, 2025); Sacramento Bee via Yahoo News (Nov. 19, 2026); Reuters via Yahoo News (Feb. 9, 2026); Vikram David Amar, Justia Verdict (Oct. 22, 2026); Fox 11 Los Angeles.
Featured image: U.S. Court House, 312 N. Spring St., Los Angeles. Photo by MikeJiroch, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
How this article was made: Right Side News researched and drafted this article with the help of AI tools. Sources are linked so readers can check them. Spot an error? Tell us in the comments and we will correct it.
