Democrats finished first in both of Louisiana’s unresolved U.S. House races on Nov. 3. The vote totals, the new map and the Supreme Court ruling that forced it tell a different story about where the 5th and 6th districts are heading on Dec. 12.
Louisiana voters return to the polls on Saturday, Dec. 12, to settle the last two U.S. House seats of the 2026 cycle in the state. In the 5th Congressional District, Democratic state Rep. Patricia “Pat” Moore of Monroe faces Republican state Rep. Gabe Firment of Pollock. In the 6th, former Baton Rouge Metro Council member Chauna Banks, a Democrat, faces Republican state Sen. Blake Miguez of New Iberia. Both seats are open, and the 6th was drawn this spring to replace a district the U.S. Supreme Court struck down as an unconstitutional racial gerrymander.
One clarification belongs at the top. These are not newly created seats. Louisiana still has six House districts. What is new is the shape of them: the Legislature rewrote the map in May after Louisiana v. Callais, and the 6th District in particular moved from a Democratic-leaning seat to a strongly Republican one on paper.
What the first-place headlines leave out
Election-night coverage led with Democrats finishing first in both races. That is accurate, and it is also incomplete. Louisiana used an all-party ballot for these House races, so every candidate ran together. Republicans fielded six candidates in each district and split their vote; Democrats fielded three in each.
In the 5th District, unofficial Secretary of State results reported by the Natchitoches Parish Journal show Moore with 40,789 votes (18%) and Firment with 39,131 (17%), a gap of 1,658 votes out of 227,917 cast. Added together, the six Republicans drew 143,717 votes, or about 63%. The three Democrats drew 84,200, or about 37%. Those totals are RSN’s own arithmetic from the published candidate counts.
The 6th District was closer at the top and wider underneath. WAFB reported Banks with 50,878 votes and Miguez with 50,213, both at 19%. Republican state Sen. Rick Edmonds finished third, fewer than 1,000 votes behind Miguez. Summing the same election-night count, the six Republicans took roughly 57% of about 262,000 votes, the three Democrats about 41%, and a Libertarian about 1%. The Louisiana Illuminator reached the same conclusion: Moore and Banks finished first “mostly because the Republican vote was split among more candidates than the Democrats had in each race.” Later unofficial updates, which remain subject to certification, show Banks’s lead over Miguez at a few hundred votes.
Ballotpedia’s district comparison, which applies 2024 presidential results to each map, puts the old 6th District at D+14.9 and the new 6th at R+30.1. The 5th moved only slightly, from R+36.4 to R+34.0. The same page lists four forecaster ratings for each seat, and all eight are Safe or Solid Republican.
Background: how Callais reset the map and the calendar
Louisiana’s 2024 map added a second majority-Black district, the old 6th, which a three-judge federal panel described as “a ‘bizarre’ 250-mile-long slash-shaped district” running from Baton Rouge to Shreveport, according to the Congressional Research Service (CRS) summary of the litigation. Democratic Rep. Cleo Fields won that seat in 2024.
On April 29, 2026, the Supreme Court affirmed that the map was “an unconstitutional racial gerrymander.” Justice Samuel Alito wrote for a 6-3 majority. Justice Elena Kagan dissented, joined by Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson. The core holding, as CRS summarizes it, is that Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act is violated “only when the evidence supports a strong inference that the State intentionally drew its districts to afford minority voters less opportunity because of their race.” The majority also said challengers must “disentangle race from politics,” because federal courts do not police partisan gerrymanders after Rucho v. Common Cause (2019).
Kagan’s dissent argued that the majority “makes a nullity of Section 2 and threatens a half-century’s worth of gains in voting equality.” That disagreement is the legal backdrop to everything that followed in Baton Rouge.
Gov. Jeff Landry postponed the state’s May 16 closed party primaries for the House. The Legislature then passed a bill moving House races to an all-party primary on Nov. 3, with a Dec. 12 runoff if no one cleared 50%, according to Associated Press reporting published by PBS. The AP reported that more than 250,000 votes had already been cast in the canceled primaries, citing the Secretary of State. Bill sponsor Rep. Beau Beaullieu, a Republican, said there was not enough time for closed primaries and primary runoffs before November.
The new map, which the AP described as similar to the one used in 2022, keeps the New Orleans-based 2nd District as the state’s single majority-Black seat and adds part of Baton Rouge to it. The 6th was rebuilt around Baton Rouge and its suburbs and parts of the River Parishes. Republican state Sen. Jay Morris was candid during the debate: “These maps are drawn to maximize Republican advantage for the incumbent Republicans that we have in Congress,” he said, per the AP. Senate President Cameron Henry said Republicans did not pursue a 6-0 map because it was not feasible.
Fields announced in July that he would not seek re-election and entered a race for the Louisiana Senate instead, WAFB reported. In the 5th, Rep. Julia Letlow gave up the seat to run for the U.S. Senate. She won that race over Democrat Jamie Davis by just over 25,000 votes, WAFB and KNOE reported.
The candidates
The Democratic nominees are not typical of their national party. The Illuminator reports that Moore calls herself an anti-abortion legislator, voted for the 2019 fetal-heartbeat bill and the 2023 ban on gender-transition treatment for minors, and was absent for the 2022 abortion-ban votes. Banks told the outlet she believes “life begins at conception.” The state Democratic Party withdrew its initial endorsement of Moore in September, partly over abortion, and backed Antonio Wilson instead; Wilson finished sixth. Party chairman Randal Gaines now expects the party to endorse both women. “Pat Moore is a conservative Democrat whose platform is perfect for that district,” he told the Illuminator.
On the Republican side, Miguez has a large financial edge. The Center Square reported in October, citing Federal Election Commission filings, that Miguez listed $6,612,410 in total receipts, including about $3.01 million in loans from himself. The same report noted that the state Republican Party endorsed both Miguez and Edmonds, that Landry had not endorsed either, and that Edmonds criticized Miguez for skipping an Oct. 9 televised debate. Firment and Moore are both sitting members of the Louisiana House.
Deep dive: what is actually at stake
House control is not on the ballot. Ballotpedia’s running tally shows Democrats with at least 255 seats after the midterms, well past the 218 needed for a majority. The Dec. 12 results will change the size of that majority by a seat or two, not who holds it.
The 6th District is a likely Republican pickup in a Democratic year. The following is RSN analysis. If Miguez wins, the seat Fields held passes from Democratic to Republican control because of a court-ordered map, not a shift in voters. In a cycle that the state Republican chairman, Derek Babcock, called “a blue wave, some say a blue tsunami,” that would be one of the few seats Republicans gain this cycle. It would also be the first concrete electoral result of Callais, and both parties are likely to cite it in redistricting fights elsewhere.
Consolidation, not persuasion, decides the runoffs. Also RSN analysis: the Republican nominees do not need to win over Democrats. They need the voters who backed Edmonds, Misti Cordell, Michael Echols and the others to return in December. The Senate race is the warning sign. Letlow’s margin of just over 25,000 votes statewide shows that Democratic turnout this year was strong enough to make a heavily Republican state competitive. The Republican advantage on paper in the 5th and 6th is far larger than that, but turnout in a December runoff is hard to predict, and RSN found no public polling of either runoff.
Money is moving in. Gaines and Babcock both told WAFB that their national parties have committed money to the two runoffs. Landry said national Republicans had treated Letlow’s race as an easy win and sent little until the final weeks. “When you look at all the carnage that happened across the country, it’s amazing that Louisiana stood tall,” he said.
Counter-arguments and the other side
Democrats argue that the map, not the voters, produced the Republican lean. During the Senate debate, Democratic state Sen. Sam Jenkins accused Republicans of “using partisanship as cover for discriminatory practices against a group of people, particularly Black voters and Democrats,” according to the AP. Kagan’s dissent makes the legal version of that point: once a state can cite a partisan goal, she wrote, vote-dilution claims under Section 2 become nearly impossible to win. Under Callais as written, however, a partisan map is lawful unless challengers prove race, not politics, drove the lines.
Democrats also point to their turnout operation. State party executive director Dadrius Lanus told WBRZ that organizers visited more than 50 cities across 50 parishes over six months. Davis finished within about two points of Letlow statewide, 49.1% to 50.9% in unofficial counts.
There is a complication for Democrats as well. Political consultant Mary Patricia Wray, who has run campaigns for former Gov. John Bel Edwards, told the Illuminator that the nominees’ social views could hurt fundraising: “A lot of out-of-state donor networks are not going to want to participate.” The Illuminator, citing OpenSecrets, reported that almost 86% of Davis’s Senate donations came from outside Louisiana.
What is established, disputed and not established
Established:
- The runoffs are on Saturday, Dec. 12, 2026, in the 5th District (Moore vs. Firment) and the 6th District (Banks vs. Miguez), per the Louisiana Secretary of State’s election calendar and local reporting.
- The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 on April 29, 2026, that the 2024 map was an unconstitutional racial gerrymander.
- Republican candidates combined for about 63% of the 5th District vote and about 57% of the 6th District vote on Nov. 3 (unofficial counts).
- Early voting runs Nov. 28 to Dec. 5, except Sunday, Nov. 29. The online registration deadline is Nov. 21, KNOE reported.
Disputed: Whether the 2026 map is a lawful partisan map or racial vote dilution under another name. Republican legislators and the Callais majority take the first view; Democratic legislators and the dissent take the second.
Not established: Who will win. No public runoff polling was found, the Nov. 3 counts are not yet certified, and December turnout is unknown. Any claim that either seat is “decided” is a forecast, not a fact.
Related RSN coverage
- Late-count flips in North Carolina and Mississippi House races
- Democratic trifectas in five states could push the popular vote compact past 270
Sources: Supreme Court, Louisiana v. Callais, No. 24-109 (April 29, 2026); Congressional Research Service, LSB11431 (May 14, 2026); AP via PBS News (May 14, 2026); WAFB (Nov. 4, 2026); Natchitoches Parish Journal (Nov. 4, 2026); WBRZ (Nov. 5, 2026); Louisiana Illuminator (Nov. 9, 2026); WAFB/KNOE (Nov. 12, 2026); KNOE (Nov. 12, 2026); The Center Square (Oct. 17, 2026); Ballotpedia; Louisiana Secretary of State.
Featured image: “Louisiana State Capitol” by StuSeeger, CC BY 2.0, via Flickr.
How this article was made: Right Side News researched and drafted this article with the help of AI tools. Sources are linked so readers can check them. Spot an error? Tell us in the comments and we will correct it.
