HomeEditorialRSN Pick of the DayThe Fallacy of Focusing on Islamic Radicalization

The Fallacy of Focusing on Islamic Radicalization

There are Jihadists from dozens of countries who have joined ISIS. What do they all have in common? The official answer is radicalization. Muslims in Europe are “radicalized” by alienation, racism and unemployment. Neglected by governments, Muslim youth band together and become terrorists. Muslims in Israel are responding to the “despair and hopelessness” of the “Occupation”. Muslims from the rest of the Middle East are angry over their “dictators”. Muslims from the Ukraine? Who knows. Radicalization comes packaged with a set of local grievances and explanations. It contends that all Muslim terrorism is a response to local conditions and that we are responsible for those conditions. Even though the “radicalization” is Islamic, it denies that Islam plays a positive role as a Jihadist goal. Instead, like Halal liquor or hashish, it’s what Muslims turn to when they have been disappointed in the West or in their own governments. Islam is just what happens when a Belgian Muslim can’t get a job. And yet Islam is the only positive uniting factor for Islamic terrorism. Why otherwise should a Moroccan youth from a French suburb who works at a nightclub, the son of a rural Saudi farmer who has never been outside his country and an American teenager who converted to Islam all risk their lives to form an Islamic State? The Jihadis of ISIS are a truly multinational and multicultural bunch. They have traveled to two foreign countries that most of them have never been to. What else unites them into a common identity that they are willing to kill and die for if it isn’t Islam? Radicalization favors local explanations. But those local explanations don’t add up nationally or globally. Europe spends a fortune on social services and yet Muslim terrorism has only grown worse. Other immigrant minorities in Europe have lower unemployment rates and aren’t blowing things up. Removing Muslim dictators in the Arab Spring didn’t lower terrorism; it vastly increased the power and influence of Islamic terror groups. Nor have changes in American foreign policy and greater outreach lowered Islamic terrorism. If anything the scale of the problem seems to have only become more severe. The Israeli peace process with the PLO likewise vastly increased the terror threat and no amount of concessions has brought peace any closer. There are stateless Muslims throughout the Middle East. Jordan is filled with the same exact “Palestinians” as Israel, many of whom are stateless and have few rights, yet terror rates are far lower. Instead Muslim violence spikes where there are religious differences. As we see in Iraq, Syria and Israel, religious differences are more explosive than political ones. And where religious differences don’t exist, Jihadists create them by denouncing their Muslim enemies as un-Islamic. ISIS is the culmination of a process that you can see among “moderate” Islamists. The official explanation is that a multitude of local factors cause Muslim disappointment leading to some sort of irreligiously religious radicalism which can be cured by preventing that disappointment. We are expected to believe that there are hundreds of explanations for Islamic terrorism, but not one. And while no doubt individual choices and emotions play a role in the making of a Muslim terrorist, the same is true in the making of a soldier. An army exists as part of a positive national ethos. Reducing an army to a series of personal dissatisfactions is absurd. So is reducing ISIS to individually dissatisfied people while ignoring what its members actually believe. It’s as absurd as believing that Hitler became a monster because he couldn’t get his painting career off the ground. Islamic terrorism is a positive ethos. It is horrifying, evil and brutal, but it is not some nihilistic void. You can look at unemployment rates in Brussels or dissatisfaction in Saudi Arabia, but nobody decides to fight and die for a Jihadist group because they’re having trouble applying for a job at McDonald’s. They join because they believe in its mission. Ignoring the organizing principle of Islamic terrorism while focusing on local conditions that might make Jihadist recruitment easier misses the forest for the trees. Radicalization programs, under euphemisms such as CVE or Countering Violent Extremism, assume that Islamic terrorism can be countered by forming a partnership with Muslim groups and social services agencies. While the West will ease Muslim dissatisfaction by providing jobs and boosting their self-esteem to make them feel like they belong, the Muslim groups will tackle the touchy issue of Islam. These partnerships achieve nothing because social services don’t prevent Islamic terrorism; they enable and fund the very no-go zones and dole-seeker lifestyles that are a gateway to the Jihad. Meanwhile the Muslim partners are inevitably Islamists looking to pick up potential recruits for their own terror agendas. Western countries fund terrorism to fight terrorism and then partner with still more terrorists to train their homegrown terrorists not to be terrorists, or at least not the wrong kind of terrorists. This is what happens when the “Islam” part of Islamic terrorism is ignored and outsourced to any Islamist who can pretend to be moderate in front of a television camera for 5 minutes at a time. None of this actually stops Islamic terrorism. Instead it empowers and encourages it. The Islamist alliances suppress any discussion of Islamic terrorism as “harming” national security. Condemn the Muslim Brotherhood and you’re interfering with CVE efforts to stop terrorism by “educating” Muslims on real Islam and helping the Brotherhood take over entire countries to address the political anger of Muslims. At least the anger of those that are part of the Muslim Brotherhood. And yet without discussing Islam, there is nothing to discuss. There are plenty of unemployed non-Muslims in Europe. There are lots of bad governments all over the world. The non-Islamic factors on which Islamic terrorism is blamed are not unique to Muslims. Only Islam is. Islamic terrorism is unique and so its causes cannot be reduced to joblessness or bad governments. A unique outcome suggests a unique cause. And Islam is a unique cause. Islam is the unique cause of Islamic terrorism. There is no way to fight Islamic terrorism without acknowledging its organizing principle, its objective and its worldview. You cannot fight “radicalization” without dealing with what Muslim terrorists are “radicalized” to do. Without Islam, all that’s left is the political and sociological hunt for individual motives while completely ignoring what unites these individuals together. And so CVE plays the seven blind men while ignoring the elephant in the room. And the terror attacks and the futile efforts to avert them continue. The issue isn’t radicalization, it’s Islamization. Islamization is what happens to individual Muslims and to Muslim communities. Islamization is also the goal of Islamic movements, overtly violent or covertly subversive. Islamization is not the answer of some radical preacher, but of the Islamic religion. This is not about jobs in Europe or democracy in Egypt. Islam is not radicalized. It is radical. Like Communism or Nazism, it offers a totalitarian answer to everything. To truly believe in Islam is to possess the conviction that every country in the world must become Islamic and be ruled by Islamic law. Islamic terrorism is one tactic for realizing this conviction. We cannot and will not defeat Islamic terror without honestly and bluntly confronting Islamization.

Source: Sultan Knish Blog]]>

1 COMMENT

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Toddy Littman on Coronavirus & Dr. Rife
jimjfox on The Islamic Scam
USAPATRIOT✓ on Coronavirus & Dr. Rife
Dumb Bass Fisherman on The Disgrace of Benghazi
Dumb Bass Fisherman on Prosecute Biden the Crook!
Dumb Bass Fisherman on The Disgrace of Benghazi
Christan on Who is Nasim Aghdam?
FarvingStartist on
Swampmom on Stubborn Syria
OhSoGood on SHOCKING Media LIES
Pbranham on
Pbranham on
Fay Butler on Lawfare, living in fear
John Cunningham on The Media and Trump at 100 Days
steve smith on
Worried on
Insanity Personified on
no mo uro on
no mo uro on
Patriotjeff on
OhSoGood on
Steve on
lovelydestruction on
Val Cocora on
Jerry Kenney on
Merlinever on
Phill Crapidy on
Clifford Ishii on
Americanmommy on
Doctor Fine on
reggiec on
DeltamanH20 on
Ms. warrior4Christ on
Comrade Molotov on
reggiec on
JEANNIEMAC2 on
Average Punter on
shamm86 on
Rich on
ort on
Lee Sargeant on
Lee Sargeant on
jcarroll4415 on
Erroldean Andrews on
charles becker on
David Miller on
charles becker on
Sophia Emma on March4Trump
UR.carrion on The Islamic Scam
pbr90 on
John Cornel Kovach on Should Islam Be Banned from America?
Lane Wingham on Rituals of Islam
Lane Wingham on Rituals of Islam
Taylor Crystaloski on Rituals of Islam
lamarlamar on California Dreaming
usaok59 on Smearing Sessions
b.a. freeman on True Islam vs Pseudo Islam
b.a. freeman on True Islam vs Pseudo Islam
Randy McDaniels on True Islam vs Pseudo Islam
Mohammad Izzaterd on True Islam vs Pseudo Islam
Bikinis not Burkas on True Islam vs Pseudo Islam
John Cornel Kovach on Should Islam Be Banned from America?
paramore309 on
Anthony Duhe on
Anthony Duhe on
Dianna9490 on
Guest✓ᵛᵉʳᶦᶠᶦᵉᵈ on Dana Rohrabacher for Secretary of State
Guest✓ᵛᵉʳᶦᶠᶦᵉᵈ on Dana Rohrabacher for Secretary of State
Abu Mohamed on
wellilltellya on The Obama Era is Over
Dianna9490 on The Obama Era is Over
reggiec on Democratic Panic
Tony Donaldson on Why Trump Will Prevail
Charlotte W on Why Trump Will Prevail
Bubba Gump on Why Trump Will Prevail
bas h on
Dianna9490 on Weaponized Immigration
Dianna9490 on Charlotte Burning
Tony Donaldson on Hillary Clinton: Basket Case
SuperDave2 on The Islamic Scam
Truthorlie on Hillary’s Race War
Proud Amelekite on We are in the End of Days
EarthCitizenNumberOne on George Soros’s Open Border Foundations
EarthCitizenNumberOne on George Soros’s Open Border Foundations
Sgt Saunders on We are in the End of Days
Proud Amelekite on We are in the End of Days
Proud Amelekite on We are in the End of Days
Saputra 007 on We are in the End of Days
Kevan Massey on We are in the End of Days
Bonnie Wolf on We are in the End of Days
Bruce Peters on We are in the End of Days
David Collins on We are in the End of Days
Monte Noffsinger on We are in the End of Days
Proud Amelekite on We are in the End of Days
Eddie Clever on The Flying Clintons
jackcandobutwont on
TSM on
Tee Quake on Born in America
shamm86 on Born in America
seersuckerandapanama on The Coming US/Mexico War
Sgt Saunders on Would Jesus Bomb Hiroshima?
michaelhayes on Would Jesus Bomb Hiroshima?
Roberta Dzubow on MUST READ: The Twisting Noose
danstewart on Why Trump Chickened Out
Uzoozy on Paul Ryan's Hijra
JEANNIEMAC2 on Importing Terror
JEANNIEMAC2 on Insane Muslim Terrorists
"The Eastern Diamondback" on King Barack the Lawless Endangers Girls
Jeff Tangen on The Cults of Islam
Joe on
amyinnh on
David Gearhart on Sex Slavery by the Numbers
David Gearhart on Sex Slavery by the Numbers
Uzoozy on The Cults of Islam
Uzoozy on The Cults of Islam
GregAbdul on The Cults of Islam
Sgt Saunders on The Cults of Islam
Uzoozy on The Cults of Islam
Uzoozy on The Cults of Islam
charles becker on American Outlaws!
GregAbdul on The Cults of Islam
GregAbdul on The Cults of Islam
Uzoozy on The Cults of Islam
Uzoozy on The Cults of Islam
Uzoozy on The Cults of Islam
GregAbdul on The Cults of Islam
Uzoozy on The Cults of Islam
Uzoozy on The Cults of Islam
Uzoozy on The Cults of Islam
GregAbdul on The Cults of Islam
GregAbdul on The Cults of Islam
Uzoozy on The Cults of Islam
smacready on The Cults of Islam
Uzoozy on The Cults of Islam
Uzoozy on The Cults of Islam
smacready on The Cults of Islam
Uzoozy on The Cults of Islam
Uzoozy on The Cults of Islam
Uzoozy on The Cults of Islam
TheBucko on The Cults of Islam
TheBucko on The Cults of Islam
smacready on The Cults of Islam
smacready on The Cults of Islam
smacready on The Cults of Islam
smacready on The Cults of Islam
smacready on The Cults of Islam
smacready on The Cults of Islam
GregAbdul on The Cults of Islam
GregAbdul on The Cults of Islam
Robin Morgan on The Cults of Islam
bob250 on The Cults of Islam
SEARING JW TRUTH on The Cults of Islam
Uzoozy on The Cults of Islam
Winston Lawrence on The Satanic Bible's 'Golden Rule'
SEARING JW TRUTH on The Cults of Islam
smacready on The Cults of Islam
sherri palmer on
John Cunningham on Jihad in Brussels
Sebastian Medina on The Coming US/Mexico War
sherri palmer on
BobWhiteRevisited✓ᴺᵃᵗᶦᵒᶰᵃˡᶦˢᵗ on Why I Stump for Trump
sherri palmer on
Kevin Alfred Strom on Support for Trump Backfires on CPAC
marlene on
marlene on
DC on
DC on
Ike_Kiefer on
sherri palmer on
sherri palmer on
Christopher Strunk on Is Trump a Sleeper Agent for Moscow?
Christopher Strunk on Is Trump a Sleeper Agent for Moscow?
usaok59 on
Chris Palmer on
RobSez on
marlene on
MayPA on
spartan111 on
John Cunningham on
Weeping Man on
felix1999 on
felix1999 on
Virgil Cole on
Virgil Cole on
Virgil Cole on
Buzg on
usaok59 on
John Cunningham on
cfd_007 on
alfy on
D Guest on
marlene on
adbj102 on
JEANNIEMAC2 on
Hugh Jass on
JEANNIEMAC2 on
Uzoozy on
TexasOlTimer on
Uzoozy on
Uzoozy on
Waiting on
TexasOlTimer on
TexasOlTimer on
<-----MyFrontDoorBuddy on
<-----MyFrontDoorBuddy on
Sarfaraz A. on
Sarfaraz A. on
Alex Sheibani on
Uzoozy on
sherri palmer on
sviri finq on
No Corporate BS on
SumatraSue on
Ted Johnson on
Waiting on
Jason Woodworth on
Helmut Beintner on
Doug Sterling on
JEANNIEMAC2 on
jwmiller on
sickandtired on
sherri palmer on
VTrobert on
Fredrick Rehders on
usaok59 on
Waiting on
VTrobert on
cool-subzero90 on
michaelhayes on
danstewart on
reggiec on
John Cunningham on
Andrew on
John Cunningham on
Don P on
Britt Brooks on
John Cunningham on
Helmut Beintner on
Jim on
Spectrum on
danstewart on
Helmut Beintner on
Helmut Beintner on
Helmut Beintner on
John Cunningham on
missinger on
adbj102 on
noh1bvisas on
danstewart on
Jigsaw on
Jigsaw on
Patty Villanova on
sherri palmer on
sherri palmer on
sherri palmer on
sherri palmer on
sherri palmer on
sherri palmer on
sherri palmer on
Weeping Man on
Frosty Wooldridge on
Hugh Jass on
danstewart on
Jr1776 on
JEANNIEMAC2 on
Fredrick Rehders on
JEANNIEMAC2 on
ort on
Jared on
dndgaddy on
Thunderbolt #1 on
JEANNIEMAC2 on
reggiec on
David Gearhart on
David Gearhart on
madgrandma on
David Gearhart on
David Gearhart on
John Wesley Bletsch on
Chopko on
LaineeTheCat Wallace on 10 Tips How to Counter Islam
LaineeTheCat ✔Trump on
LaineeTheCat ✔Trump on
danstewart on
marlene on
marlene on
felix1999 on
felix1999 on
felix1999 on
ort on
ort on
felix1999 on
felix1999 on
felix1999 on
<-----MyFrontDoorBuddy on
marlene on
Helmut Beintner on
Whynot be great again222 on
JEANNIEMAC2 on
ort on
michaelhayes on
John Wesley Bletsch on
missinger on
missinger on
missinger on
Whynot be great again222 on
Whynot be great again222 on
Whynot be great again222 on
Whynot be great again222 on
Whynot be great again222 on
Whynot be great again222 on
Whynot be great again222 on
ort on
Allright Hamilton! on
ort on
Allright Hamilton! on
Allright Hamilton! on
TheBucko on
ort on
ort on
ZEPHANIAH54321 on
mzliberty2013 on
JEANNIEMAC2 on
Frosty Wooldridge on
Jim on
Frosty Wooldridge on
Whynot be great again222 on
Jawad Karim on
Tranqual on
Allright Hamilton! on
Whynot be great again222 on
Allright Hamilton! on
danstewart on
ort on
marlene on
satovey on The Islamic Scam
Tranqual on
Tranqual on
madgrandma on
durabo on
Warrior on
marlene on
reggiec on
reggiec on
marlene on
marlene on
marlene on
marlene on
marlene on
deanosslewis . on The Islamic Scam
asinnersavedbygrace on Top Bible Prophecy Stories of 2015
Jill Hasselbach Villalba on The New Terror Threat: Organized Rape
malaka_eneuresis on The Islamic Scam
TexasOlTimer on Trump Gets It: The Snake
maddog0311 on Trump Gets It: The Snake
John Cunningham on US Criminalizing Free Speech?
Michael Bluestein on Burns, Oregon, Is Not Bundy Ranch
John Cunningham on US Criminalizing Free Speech?
John Cunningham on US Criminalizing Free Speech?
John Cunningham on US Criminalizing Free Speech?
John Cunningham on US Criminalizing Free Speech?
sherri palmer on What Muslims Really Believe
David Gearhart on What Muslims Really Believe
wildmanonearth on Sharia Law for the Non-Muslim
Vladsmom on
bruce on Chelm
John Cunningham on ISIS Campaign for Europe
John Cunningham on Being Thankful for the Left
marlene on  GOP Plot Thickens
Fredrick Neal Rehders on Media Darling Conservatives
Sgt Saunders on Red-Faced Fury
Fredrick Neal Rehders on America Isn’t Dead Yet
funk u zionist bedouin on Red-Faced Fury
Fredrick Neal Rehders on Empty the Prisons Bill Now on Fast Track
NetJobsOnline~~~~Earn $97/hour on The Obama Machine Takes Over Canada
NetJobsOnline~~~~Earn $97/hour on The Death of Europe
NetJobsOnline~~~~Earn $97/hour on A Big Stash of Campaign Cash in Marijuana for Paul
kunling on The Death of Europe
Richard N on The Death of Europe
Yours Truly on Sweden Close to Collapse
John Cunningham on Sweden Close to Collapse
michaelhayes on Sweden Close to Collapse
michaelhayes on Sweden Close to Collapse
Doc Eckleberg on Sweden Close to Collapse
John Cunningham on Legitimizing Hillary’s Crimes
John Cunningham on Sweden Close to Collapse
Enos Dapenis on The Coming US/Mexico War
Fucck your lies on The Coming US/Mexico War
BornAgainSouthernPride on Obama and a Doctrine of Dishonesty
GooglePostJobs:::GET $97/h on Chinese Government Runs Circles Around Obama
GooglePostJobs:::GET $97/h on JW Exposes Hillary Clinton Lie
John Cunningham on JW Exposes Hillary Clinton Lie
Yours Truly on I Am Mourning For America
Yours Truly on I Am Mourning For America
Prophetess Anya Kelly on Are We Living In The Last Days?
disqus_NSXp0ZCum6 on Should Christians Call God Allah?
Tee Quake on Nuclear Jihad
ort on
Jim on
Joel Spealman on Is Trump the Real Deal?
RobertLaity on
DENNIS J. MALONE on Is Trump the Real Deal?
ort on
Manorbier on
Bo Wetstone on The Banking Oligarchs
Dannie Poe on
JohnDiLiberto on The Banking Oligarchs
Herman Van Keer on Answering Muslims Conference
Mean Green Law on Donald Trump: American Patriot
Jigsaw on Trumping Trump
b keaton on Trumping Trump